76 KiB
76 KiB
<html>
<head></head>
<body>
<20>WPC<50>> <00><> <00>Rpu <20>]<5D><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>#<23>k<02>]<5D><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> {<7B>&<3B>[<5B> <0B>i<> <1E><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>>hy<68><79><EFBFBD><16>?NA<12><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>a.%3<><33>=<3D><>{<7B><>4N<34><4E>^<02><><EFBFBD>}<7D>'ȧ<>oaTQ$n<>~ŧ<>!b<>?r<>~[J#L<19>WBL<42><4C><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>iI<69> <20>T<<3B><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>9<EFBFBD> <1C><>[2<><32><EFBFBD>I& <20><><EFBFBD>N5<4E><1A><>W}<7D><>c!<21>8-<2D><><EFBFBD><19>v<1A><><EFBFBD>*c@)<29><><EFBFBD>Sb<53>F<EFBFBD><46><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>49<34><39><EFBFBD>G<EFBFBD>f 5[<5B><>P9<50>hPmx-<2D><>C<EFBFBD>W<EFBFBD><57><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>Z<EFBFBD>gz<67><7A>O)4 Y0<59><30><EFBFBD>(Fc<46><63>i/<2F>"<22><>yb<79> <1D><> ԩDGW<47>xBP<42><50>7<EFBFBD>>"v<><76><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>Z<EFBFBD>&<3B>~<7E><>=<3D><><EFBFBD>{<>'<27><19><><EFBFBD>z<EFBFBD><7A><05>mO<6D><4F>O%<25>:Jc<4A><63><EFBFBD>0pʙR}<7D><>O<EFBFBD>!<21><EFBFBD>eW )<29>:<3A>0k<30><6B><EFBFBD>x<EFBFBD><78><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>KoIq⋼ <20><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>d5<64><0F>H|~<7E>N<EFBFBD>e<EFBFBD><65>'<27><>e#<23><>鲇<EFBFBD><E9B287>:<3A><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>r<><72><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>C>:<3A>U)<29><>)* ~<7E>1<EFBFBD>8Y<1A> 6<>ϟ#<23><>Vl?m<><6D>h<05>hD<68> <20>|lm<6C>p=, <1F>Uӭׯ)<29><>W %<25><>} ; U : : % t 0 <00> z 0 R \ <00> <00> O e 0 S <00> <00> 0 <00> <00> t <00> 0 , <00> ; 0 <00> <00> <00> ~ 0 <00> <00> <00> 0 <00> @ 0 z <00> 0 <00> m 0 <00> <00> <00> 0 O l E <00> 0 <00> <00> <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>! <00>! <00>! n <00> <00>! 0 4 <00>" B <00>" <00>" <00>" w @ <00>( 1 ) 0 P O) U V <00>) 4 <00>) U V * _* m a* 1 x* <00>* U V <00>0 U : 1 1 ?1 p1 U V v7 U : <00>7 1 8 78 U V => U : <00>> <00>> <00>> < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i X <00> Z <20><>6 N u m - L i s t 2 n u m b e r e d l i s t , b l a n k l i n e b e t w e e n i t e m s <00><> . . <00><> <00><>2 <00>1.<2E>3 Ԁ<><D480> <00><> <00><>0 . . <00><><EFBFBD> h <00> <10>6 L e t t e r - R e c L e t t e r o f r e c o m m e n d a t i o n <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><><EFBFBD>Letter<65>of<6F>recommendation<6F>for<6F> <00> <00> <00> XQ' <00><> <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><0E>Suber<65> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E> ( ' 2XQ$ <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> <00> ^ <00> &<3B>8 M e m o - F o r m a l F o r m a l m e m o h e a d e r <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><><EFBFBD>To:<3A><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00>From:<3A><>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00>Date:<3A><><EFBFBD>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><><EFBFBD>Re:<3A><> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><0E><> <00><> <00>Suber,<2C><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E> v P <10><>: M e m o - I n f o r m l J u s t m y n a m e a n d c u r r e n t d a t e <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><> <00> <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><> <00> <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><> j <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>. <00> <00> <10>=8 L e t t e r - H o m e L e t t e r w i t h m y h o m e a d d r e s s a s r e t u r n a d d r e s s <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>235<33>South<74>Third<72>Street<65><74> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Richmond,<2C>Indiana<6E><61>47374<37><34> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>317<31>/<2F>962<36>2533<33><33><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>. R e <10><>, E s s a y g e n e r a l f o r e s s a y s <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Department<6E>of<6F>Philosophy<68><79> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Earlham<61>College<67><65> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Richmond,<2C>Indiana<6E><61>47374<37><34><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Copyright<68>(c)<29>1989<38> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><0E>Suber<65> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E> <00> <10>#4 L e t t e r - E C L e t t e r w i t h m y o f f i c e a d d r e s s a s r e t u r n a d d r e s s <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Department<6E>of<6F>Philosophy<68><79> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Earlham<61>College<67><65> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Richmond,<2C>Indiana<6E><61>47374<37><34><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>317<31>/<2F>983<38>1214<31><34><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>. P M <04><>0 H e a d i n g C h a p t e r H e a d i n g <00><>@ <00>. . <00><><02><> <20><> <00><>2 <00>I.<2E>3 Ԁ<> <00><> Ԉ<><D488><EFBFBD><02><> <20> R & <20><>8 B i b l i o g r p h y B i b l i o g r a p h y <00>0 . . <00><> <00>. . <00><><EFBFBD> L H <04><>6 S u b h e a d i n g S u b h e a d i n g <00> <20><> <00><>2 <00>A.<2E>3 <00><> . . <00><> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <20> x ? <10>t2 P l e a d i n g H e a d e r f o r n u m b e r e d p l e a d i n g p a p e r <00> <00> <00><> <03> <00><> <00><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00> <00> <00> XQ( <00><> <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><> <00> <00><> X<02> <00><> <00><04> <00><> <00><><02><01> <00>X <00><>? <00>" ' <00> <00> <00>*<2A> dE<64><03> <00>*? <00><>? <00>" ' <00> <00>*<2A> dE<04> <00>*? <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>1<EFBFBD><31><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>2<EFBFBD><32><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>3<EFBFBD><33><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>4<EFBFBD><34><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>5<EFBFBD><35><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>6<EFBFBD><36><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>7<EFBFBD><37><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>8<EFBFBD><38><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>9<EFBFBD><39><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>10<31><30><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>11<31><31><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>12<31><32><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>13<31><33><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>14<31><34><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>15<31><35><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>16<31><36><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>17<31><37><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>18<31><38><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>19<31><39><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>20<32><30><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>21<32><31><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>22<32><32><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>23<32><33><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>24<32><34><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>25<32><35><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>26<32><36><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>27<32><37><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>28<32> <00>.<2E>+ <00> ( ' 2XQ$ <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> <00> <00> Z <20><>6 N u m - L i s t 1 N u m b e r e d l i s t , n o b l a n k b e t w e e n i t e m s <00><> . . <00><> <00><>2 <00>I.<2E>3 Ԁ<><D480> <00><> <00><>0 . . <00><> <00> <00> <00> XQ' <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>* X<02>K X X X <00><> 8<04> <00><> 8<04> <00><><0E>Weekly<6C>explication<6F>topics<63>&<3B>reading<6E>questions<6E> <00><><EFBFBD> \!\!E <00># <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E><> <01> <00><> <00>see<65>\books\<5C>kantkdrv<72><76>for<6F>this<69>document<6E>supplemented<65>with<74>page<67>numbers<72>attached<65>to<74>each<63>entry,<2C>and<6E>other<65>notes̄<73>don<6F> <04>t<EFBFBD>revise<73>this<69>doc<6F>without<75>revising<6E>that<61>one<6E>accordingly,<2C>and<6E>vice<63>versā<61>this<69>one<6E>is<69>for<6F>handing<6E>out<75>to<74>students;<3B>the<68>other<65>is<69>for<6F>me<6D>to<74>lead<61>discussion <00> <00> #| x <00> <00> < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i X<02>x <00>6X @<40> <00>8<EFBFBD> X@ ( <12>U$ <00> <00> <00> <00> d <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>( X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00> X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00> <00> E <00> -<02> <00> <00> E <00> -<02> ( -<02> <00> <00> <00> <00> <00> $ <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X ( ( 3^<5E>$ <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r ;<3B>6% <00><01><> <20><> ~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r <00>U<1A><> <00><><EFBFBD> . <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>/ X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00>0 X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i 2 <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>3 X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00>4 X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i 6 <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>7 X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00>8 X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i <00> H <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> ݛ<> 8<04> <00><> 8<04> <00><> <00><> <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> = <00><> . <00><> 8 <00><04><><01> <00>X Ӣ<> <00> <00>8h <1F> ԣ<> <00>( X<02>K X X X <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><> r <00><> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> z <00><> < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> D <00><> <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00> <00><> r <00><> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> z <00><> < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> D <00><> <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>January<72>5,<2C>1999<39>! <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <20><>@ <00> <00>Weekly<6C>Explication<6F>Topics<63>and<6E>Reading<6E>Questions<6E> <20><> 8 T <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00> <00><> r <00>The<68>questions<6E>arise<73>from<6F>the<68>reading<6E>for<6F>the<68>day<61>under<65>which<63>they<65>are<72>listed.<2E><>The<68>explication<6F>topics<63>arise<73>either<65>that<61>day<61>or<6F>the<68>day<61>preceding.<2E> <00> <00><><02> <00><>% <00> <00><><03> <00><><01> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>& l <00><> <20>Day<61>1.<2E> <20>Syllabus;<3B>generic<69>hand-out;<3B>from<6F>the<68><65>Critique<75>:<3A>Table<6C>of<6F>Contents;<3B>Prefaces<65>to<74>first<73>and<6E> <01><0E> <00>second<6E>editions,<2C><>A.vii<69>-xxii,<2C><>B.vii<69>-<2D>xliv<69>;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>ix-xiii,<2C>7-37<33><37><02> <00><><EFBFBD><03> <00>Thesis<69>for<6F>explication<6F> <00> <00>:<3A><01> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61><74>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>synthetic<69>judgments<74>are<72>necessary<72>for<6F>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F>experience;<3B> Pl r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>revolutionary<72>about<75>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD><73> <04>revolutionary<72> <04><>idea?<3F> $ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>notion<6F>of<6F>metaphysics?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>positive<76>and<6E>the<68>negative<76>value<75>of<6F>critique?<3F> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>will<6C>a<EFBFBD>critique<75>of<6F>reason<6F>decide<64>the<68>question<6F>of<6F>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F>metaphysics?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><17> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>are<72>Galileo<65> <04>s<EFBFBD>and<6E><64>Torricelli<6C><69> <04>s<EFBFBD>experiments<74>(<28>B.xiif<69>)<29>examples<65>of<6F>reason<6F>knowing<6E>only<6C> <01><18> <00>that<61>which<63>it<69>produces<65>after<65>a<EFBFBD>plan<61>of<6F>its<74>own?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>speculative<76>and<6E>practical<61>reason?<3F><>How<6F>do<64>they<65>differ?<3F> x<1A> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>would<6C>trespassing<6E>beyond<6E>the<68>limits<74>of<6F>experience<63>destroy<6F>practical<61>reason?<3F><> `| r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>differences<65>do<64>you<6F>notice<63>between<65>the<68>prefaces<65>to<74>the<68>first<73>and<6E>second<6E>editions?<3F> H d r<06>#r<06># <00><>' l<03><0E> <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>2.<2E> <20>Introduction,<2C>B.1-30;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>41-62<36> 4 <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>we<77>know<6F>that<61>experience<63>and<6E>science<63>are<72><65> <04>actual<61> <04><>such<63>that<61>we<77>can<61>or<6F>must<73>seek<65> <01> <20>!" <00>the<68>conditions<6E>of<6F>their<69><72> <04>possibility<74> <04>?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>a<EFBFBD>concept<70><74> <04>contain<69>a<EFBFBD>manifold<6C> <04><>such<63>that<61>analysis<69>can<61>disclose<73>it?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>"<22>#$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69><73><02> <00><> <04><><03> <00>7<EFBFBD>+<2B>5<EFBFBD>=<3D><>12<31><02> <00><> <04><><03> <00><><02> <00><>% <00>: <00><><03> <00>synthetic?<3F> <01>#<23>$% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>causal<61>judgments<74>synthetic?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>they<65><79>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>?<3F><> t$<24>%& r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Would<6C>Hume<6D>agree<65>that<61>they<65>are<72>synthetic?<3F><>that<61>they<65>are<72><65>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>?<3F> \%x&' <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>the<68><65>Critique<75>a<EFBFBD><61> <04>canon<6F> <04><>or<6F>an<61><6E> <04>organon<6F> <04>?<3F> D&`'( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>synthetic<69><63>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>judgements?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>they<65>possible?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>they<65> ,'H() <00>important?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><02> <00><> <00><><03> <00><><01> <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>3.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic,<2C>Sections<6E>1-5,<2C>B.33-49;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>65-76<37> <01>*<2A>+- Ѐ<><D080> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>time<6D>and<6E>space<63>have<76>empirical<61>reality<74>and<6E>transcendental<61>ideality;<3B># <01>-<2D>.0 r<06>#r<06>#= # <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>unknowability<74>of<6F>things<67>in<69>themselves<65>is<69>necessary<72>for<6F>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F> <00>synthetic<69><63>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>judgments;<3B> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>a<EFBFBD>transcendental<61>aesthetic?<3F><>(How<6F>is<69>it<69>transcendental?<3F><>How<6F>is<69>it<69>an<61>aesthetic?)<29> <01> <0B> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>intuition?<3F> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>sensation<6F>and<6E>intuition?<3F> <01> p r<06>#r<06># М<> <00> <00><><02> <00><>% <00>9 <00><><03> <00><><01> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>the<68>matter<65>and<6E>form<72>of<6F>sensation?<3F> <01>X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>pure<72>and<6E>empirical<61>intuition?<3F> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>inner<65>and<6E>outer<65>sense?<3F> X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Exactly<6C>what<61>in<69>intuition<6F>is<69><73>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>and<6E>what<61>is<69><73>a<EFBFBD>posteriori<72>?<3F> @ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>empirical<61>reality<74>and<6E>transcendental<61>ideality<74>(for<6F>time<6D> (<12> <00>and<6E>space)?<3F><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>Kant<6E>saying<6E>that<61>the<68>entire<72>world<6C>of<6F>space<63>and<6E>all<6C>objects<74>in<69>space,<2C>and<6E>the<68>entire<72>world<6C> <01><13> <00>of<6F>time<6D>and<6E>all<6C>objects<74>in<69>time,<2C>are<72><65> <04>just<73>in<69>my<6D>head<61> <04>?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>intuitions<6E>and<6E>concepts?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><15> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>it<69>true<75>that<61>in<69>experience<63>no<6E>question<6F>is<69>ever<65>asked<65>about<75>the<68>thing<6E>in<69>itself?<3F><>(See<65>B.45.)<29> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>Kant<6E>sure<72>that<61>the<68>forms<6D>of<6F>time<6D>and<6E>space<63>do<64>not<6F>apply<6C>to<74>things<67>in<69>themselves?<3F> <01>h r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>must<73>time<6D>and<6E>space<63>be<62>forms<6D>of<6F>intuition<6F>rather<65>than<61>concepts?<3F> <01>P r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>4.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic,<2C>Sections<6E>6-8,<2C>B.49-73;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>76-92<39> P <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>more<72>objects<74>in<69>time<6D>than<61>in<69>space?<3F><><EFBFBD> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>inner<65>and<6E>outer<65>sense?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>sensible<6C>and<6E>intellectual<61>intuition?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>is<69>human<61>intuition<6F>sensible<6C>rather<65>than<61>intellectual?<3F> <01> <1F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>God<6F> <04>s<EFBFBD>knowledge<67>intuitive<76>rather<65>than<61>conceptual?<3F><> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>appearance<63>and<6E>illusion?<3F><> <01>!d r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>concept<70>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>number?<3F> |"L r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>physics<63>make<6B>use<73>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>time<6D>and<6E>space?<3F> d#4 r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>there<72>no<6E>privileged<65>access<73>to<74>the<68>self?<3F><><EFBFBD> L$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic<69>express<73>or<6F>fulfill<6C>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>revolutionary<72>hypothesis?<3F> 4% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic<69>an<61>organon?<3F><> &<3B> ! r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Was<61>the<68>conflict<63>of<6F>reason<6F>with<74>itself,<2C>or<6F>any<6E>other<65>source<63>of<6F>error,<2C>found<6E>in<69>the<68> '<27> " <00>Aesthetic?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>5.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Logic,<2C>B.74-101;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>92-110<31> <01>)<29>!% <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>transcendental<61>logic<69>is<69>not<6F>formal,<2C>but<75>has<61>content;<3B><> x,H$( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>judgment<6E>is<69>the<68>mediate<74>knowledge<67>of<6F>objects;<3B><> `-0%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>concepts<74>rest<73>on<6F>functions<6E>of<6F>unity;<3B><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>pure<72>concepts<74>(can)<29>apply<6C><79>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>to<74>objects;<3B> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>thoughts<74>without<75>content<6E>empty,<2C>and<6E>intuitions<6E>without<75>concepts<74>blind?<3F><>What<61> <01> <0B> <00>are<72><65> <04>emptiness<73> <04><>and<6E><64> <04>blindness<73> <04><>here?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>intuitions<6E>and<6E>concepts<74>explain<69>the<68>transition<6F>from<6F>the<68> <01> p <00>Aesthetic<69>to<74>the<68>Logic?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>Transcendental<61>Logic<69>a<EFBFBD>faculty?<3F>a<EFBFBD>science?<3F> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>pure<72>and<6E>empirical<61>concepts?<3F> X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>there<72>no<6E>sufficient<6E>and<6E>general<61>criterion<6F>of<6F>truth?<3F> @ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Given<65>this,<2C>what<61>is<69>the<68>status<75>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>concern<72>for<6F>truth?<3F><>What<61>is<69>his<69>notion<6F>of<6F> (<12> <00>truth?<3F><>In<49>what<61>sense<73>does<65>he<68>claim<69>truth<74>for<6F>his<69>results<74>and<6E>in<69>what<61>sense<73>not?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>analytic<69>and<6E>dialectical<61>logic?<3F> <01><13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>result<6C>of<6F>using<6E>general<61>logic<69>(which<63>is<69>a<EFBFBD>canon)<29>as<61>an<61>organon?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><14> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68><65> <04>clue<75> <04><>to<74>the<68>discovery<72>of<6F>all<6C>pure<72>concepts?<3F><> <01><15> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>Kant<6E>call<6C>the<68>understanding<6E>an<61><6E> <04>absolute<74>unity<74> <04><>(B.92)?<3F> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># Ѐ<> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>concepts<74>predicates?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>h r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>judgments?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>arrive<76>at<61>it?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>he<68>sure<72>it<69>is<69>accurate<74> <01>P <00>and<6E>complete?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>6.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Concepts,<2C>B.102-29;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>111-28<32> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>relation<6F>between<65>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>judgments<74>and<6E>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>categories?<3F><>Why<68> <01> <1D> <00>does<65>he<68>need<65>both?<3F><>How<6F>did<69>he<68>get<65>from<6F>the<68>former<65>to<74>the<68>latter?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>categories<65>known<77>to<74>be<62>complete?<3F> <01> <1F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>third<72>category<72>in<69>each<63>triad<61>arise<73>from<6F>the<68>combination<6F>of<6F>the<68>first<73>two?<3F> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>categories?<3F> <01>!d r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>synthesis?<3F> |"L r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Are<72>the<68>structures<65>of<6F>cognition<6F>shared<65>by<62>all<6C>rational<61>beings?<3F><>Are<72>they<65>subject<63>to<74> d#4 <00>historical<61>change<67>or<6F>evolution?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>method<6F>has<61>Kant<6E>used<65>to<74>learn<72>the<68>structures<65>of<6F>cognition?<3F><>How<6F>have<76>these<73> 4% <00>structures<65>come<6D>to<74>know<6F>themselves?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>a<EFBFBD>transcendental<61>deduction?<3F><>What<61>is<69>its<74>task?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>necessary<72>to<74>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD> '<27> " <00>project?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>we<77>know<6F>that<61>the<68>categories<65>apply<6C><79>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>to<74>objects?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>(<28> $ r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>7.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Deduction<6F>in<69>the<68>A<EFBFBD>edition,<2C>A.95-130;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>129-50<35> <01>*t"& <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><> x,H$( <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>a<EFBFBD>unity<74>of<6F>consciousness<73>is<69>required<65>to<74>ground<6E>the<68>knowledge<67>(or<6F>experience)<29>of<6F> <00><> <00>objects;<3B> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>unity<74>of<6F>rules<65>(concepts,<2C>categories)<29>grounds<64>the<68>empirical<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception;<3B> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>transcendental<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>is<69>the<68>ground<6E>of<6F>all<6C>concepts;<3B> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>empirical<61>consciousness<73>(and<6E>its<74>unity)<29>presuppose<73>a<EFBFBD>transcendental<61>consciousness<73> <01> <0B> <00>(and<6E>its<74>unity).<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>central<61>task<73>or<6F>question<6F>of<6F>the<68>transcendental<61>deduction?<3F><>(Part<72>of<6F>the<68>answer<65> p@ <00>appeared<65>in<69>last<73>week<65> <04>s<EFBFBD>reading,<2C>and<6E>part<72>appears<72>in<69>this<69>week<65> <04>s.)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>is<69>this<69>task<73>important<6E>to<74>his<69>program<61>in<69>the<68><65>Critique<75>as<61>you<6F>understand<6E>it<69>so<73> @ <00>far?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>A<EFBFBD>version<6F>of<6F>the<68>deduction<6F>meet<65>the<68>task<73>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>deduction?<3F><>Drop<6F>out<75> <13> <00>inessential<61>detail<69>and<6E>try<72>to<74>state<74>the<68>question<6F>Kant<6E>is<69>trying<6E>to<74>address<73>and<6E>the<68>answer<65>provided<65>by<62>the<68>deduction.<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>the<68>transcendental<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>the<68>producer<65>or<6F>the<68>product<63>of<6F>the<68>categories?<3F><> <01><15> <00>both?<3F><>neither?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>understanding<6E>a<EFBFBD>derivative<76>faculty?<3F> <01>h r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>understanding<6E>determine<6E>sensibility?<3F> <01>P r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>8.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Deduction<6F>in<69>the<68>B<EFBFBD>edition,<2C>B.129-69;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>151-75<37> P <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>first<73>and<6E>second<6E>editions<6E>of<6F>the<68>deduction<6F>differ?<3F> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>empirical<61>and<6E>transcendental<61>apperception?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>empirical<61>consciousness<73>presuppose<73>pure<72>consciousness?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>deduction<6F>set<65>limits<74>to<74>the<68>valid<69>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>categories?<3F> <01> <1F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>Kant<6E>know<6F>that<61>no<6E>categories<65>apply<6C>to<74>noumena?<3F><>Or,<2C>how<6F>can<61>he<68>know<6F>that<61> <01> | <00>their<69>valid<69>employment<6E>is<69>limited<65>to<74>objects<74>of<6F>experience?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>differences<65>among<6E>the<68>original<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>and<6E>the<68>other<65>(derived)<29> |"L <00>unities<65>of<6F>apperception?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>each<63>other?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>e.g.<2E>synthetic<69>unity,<2C>analytic<69>unity,<2C>objective<76>unity,<2C>transcendental<61>unity,<2C>subjective<76> L$ <00>unity,<2C>empirical<61>unity<74> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>should<6C>we<77>distinguish<73>judgments<74>about<75>objects<74>valid<69>only<6C>under<65>my<6D>subjective<76> &<3B> ! <00>(<28>Humean<61>)<29>associations<6E>and<6E>habits<74>from<6F>judgments<74>valid<69>for<6F>all,<2C>publicly,<2C>objectively?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>preserve<76>the<68>public,<2C><>sharable<6C><65>character<65>of<6F>knowledge?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>he<68>avoid<69> <01>'<27> # <00>the<68>conclusion<6F>that<61>consciousness<73>generates<65>all<6C>there<72>is?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>he<68>avoid<69>solipsism?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>are<72>we<77>the<68>law-givers<72>to<74>nature?<3F> <01>)<29>!% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>should<6C>we<77>distinguish<73>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>consciousness<73>that<61>is<69>the<68>same<6D>in<69>each<63>of<6F>us<75>from<6F> <01>*t"& <00>the<68>self<6C>that<61>is<69>different<6E>in<69>each<63>of<6F>us?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>should<6C>we<77>distinguish<73>the<68>I<EFBFBD>that<61>thinks<6B>from<6F>the<68>I<EFBFBD>that<61>intuits<74>itself?<3F><><EFBFBD> t,D$( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kinds<64>of<6F>self<6C>are<72>there?<3F><>What<61><74>is<69>a<EFBFBD>human<61>being?<3F> \-,%) r<06>#r<06># ЇIf<49>you<6F> <04>re<72>feeling<6E>especially<6C>courageous<75>and<6E>adventuresome,<2C>here<72>are<72>some<6D>more<72>specific<69>questions:<3A><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>analysis<69>presuppose<73>synthesis<69>more<72>than,<2C>or<6F>rather<65>than,<2C>vice<63>versa?<3F> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Does<65>this<69>help<6C>us<75>figure<72>out<75>how<6F>the<68>analytic<69>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>presupposes<65>the<68> <20> <00>synthetic<69>unity<74>of<6F>apperception?<3F><>(B.133<EFBFBD>and<EFBFBD>B.133.<2E>n.)<29><> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>necessary<72>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>an<61>analytic<69>proposition<6F>that<61>nevertheless<73> <01> <0B> <00>reveals<6C>the<68>necessity<74>of<6F>synthesis?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>understanding<6E><67> <04>the<68>faculty<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>itself<6C> <04><>(B.134.n),<2C><> <04>nothing<6E>but<75>the<68> <01> p <00>faculty<74>of<6F>combining<6E><67>a<EFBFBD>priori<72><69> <04><>(B.135)<29><> <04>and<6E>of<6F>bringing<6E>the<68>manifold<6C>of<6F>given<65> <01>X <00>representations<6E>under<65>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F> <04><>(B.135)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>an<61>object<63><74> <04>that<61>in<69>the<68>concept<70>of<6F>which<63>the<68>manifold<6C>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>given<65>intuition<6F>is<69> X <00>unified<65> <04><>(B.137),<2C>or<6F><72> <04>a<EFBFBD>determinate<74>space<63> <04><>(B.138)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>copula<6C>express<73>the<68>relation<6F>of<6F>subject<63>and<6E>predicate<74><65> <04>to<74>original<61> (<12> <00>apperception<6F> <04><>(B.142)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>role<6C>of<6F>imagination<6F>in<69>the<68>argument<6E>of<6F>the<68><65> <04>A<EFBFBD> <04><>deduction?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>missing<6E> <01><13> <00>from<6F>the<68><65> <04>B<EFBFBD> <04><>edition?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>9.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C><>Schematism<73>,<2C>B.169-87;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>176-87<38> <01><16> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>a<EFBFBD>schema<6D>is<69>in<69>one<6E>respect<63>intellectual<61>and<6E>in<69>another<65>sensible;<3B><> l< r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>a<EFBFBD>schema<6D>is<69>necessary<72>for<6F>a<EFBFBD>concept<70>to<74>stand<6E>in<69>relation<6F>to<74>an<61>object;<3B><> T$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F>experience<63>gives<65>objective<76>reality<74>to<74>all<6C>our<75><72>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>modes<65>of<6F> < <00>knowledge;<3B><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>all<6C>intuitions<6E>are<72>extensive<76>magnitudes;<3B><> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>there<72>is<69>an<61><6E>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>anticipation<6F>of<6F>something<6E>empirical<61>and<6E>sensory;<3B><> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>concepts<74>and<6E>principles?<3F> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>central<61>task<73>or<6F>question<6F>of<6F>the<68><65>schematism<73>?<3F><>How<6F>is<69>it<69>similar<61>to,<2C>and<6E> <01>!d <00>different<6E>from,<2C>the<68>central<61>task<73>or<6F>question<6F>of<6F>the<68>deduction?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>both<74>chapters<72>necessary?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>subsumption?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>a<EFBFBD>problem?<3F> L$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>time<6D>fitted<65>to<74>render<65>concepts<74>and<6E>intuitions<6E><73> <04>homogenous<75> <04>?<3F><><EFBFBD> 4% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>are<72>schemata,<2C>images,<2C>and<6E>concepts<74>to<74>be<62>distinguished?<3F> &<3B> ! r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>do<64>schemata,<2C>rather<65>than<61>images,<2C>underlie<69>pure<72>sensible<6C>concepts?<3F> '<27> " r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>schemata<74>match<63>or<6F>correspond<6E>to<74>the<68>categories?<3F> <01>'<27> # r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>schemata<74>simultaneously<6C><79> <04>realize<7A> <04><>and<6E><64> <04>restrict<63> <04><>the<68>application<6F>of<6F>the<68> <01>(<28> $ <00>categories?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Are<72>there<72>schemata<74>for<6F>empirical<61>concepts,<2C>or<6F>only<6C>for<6F>pure<72>concepts<74>(categories)?<3F> <01>*t"& r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Now<6F>that<61>you<6F>know<6F>what<61>schemata<74>are,<2C>how<6F><77>do<64>we<77>perform<72>subsumption?<3F> <01>+\#' r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>principles<65>match<63>or<6F>correspond<6E>to<74>the<68>categories?<3F> t,D$( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>principles<65>provide<64>rules<65>for<6F>the<68>objective<76>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>categories?<3F><><EFBFBD> \-,%) r<06>#r<06># Ї<> <20>Day<61>10.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C>Axioms<6D>and<6E>Anticipations,<2C>B.187-218;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>188-208<30> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>axioms<6D>of<6F>intuition?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>or<6F>why<68>do<64>they<65>align<67>with<74>the<68>categories<65>of<6F>quantity?<3F> <01> <0B> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>anticipations<6E>of<6F>perception?<3F> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>or<6F>why<68>do<64>they<65>align<67>with<74>the<68>categories<65>of<6F>quality?<3F> <01> t <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>the<68>axioms<6D>called<65><64> <04>axioms<6D> <04>?<3F> <01>\ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>highest<73>principle<6C>of<6F>all<6C>analytic<69>judgments?<3F><> tD r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>highest<73>principle<6C>of<6F>all<6C>synthetic<69>judgments?<3F> \ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F><66> <04>self-evident<6E> <04><>truths?<3F><><EFBFBD> D r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>pure<72>mathematics<63>apply<6C>to<74>objects?<3F><><EFBFBD> ,<12> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD>& <00> <00><> <20>Day<61>11.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C>Analogies,<2C>' <00> <03>{T ԀB.218-265;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>208-38<33> <01><13> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00>̀<EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>changing<6E>appearances,<2C>and<6E>time<6D>itself,<2C>presuppose<73>an<61>unchanging<6E>substance;<3B> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>our<75>subjective<76>synthesis<69>can<61>be<62>made<64>objective<76>only<6C>by<62>a<EFBFBD>rule<6C>of<6F>causation;<3B><> <01>p r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>analogies<65>(taken<65>together)<29>indicate<74>that<61>all<6C>appearances<65>lie<69>in<69>only<6C>one<6E>nature;<3B><><EFBFBD> <01>X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>not<6F>all<6C><6C>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>certainties<65>are<72>demonstrable;<3B> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>material<61>idealism<73>is<69>false;<3B><> X( r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Do<44>the<68>analogies<65>seem<65>constitutive<76>to<74>you?<3F> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>the<68>analogies<65>called<65><64> <04>analogies<65> <04>?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>difference<63>between<65>things<67>in<69>themselves<65>and<6E>substance?<3F> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>prevents<74>us<75>from<6F>ordering<6E>things<67>temporally<6C>in<69>different<6E>ways?<3F> <01> <1F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>status<75>does<65>the<68>principle<6C>of<6F>sufficient<6E>reason<6F>have<76>for<6F>Kant?<3F><>For<6F>example,<2C>is<69>it<69> <01> <20> <00>empirically<6C>real<61>and<6E>transcendentally<6C>ideal?<3F><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Are<72>noumena<6E>subject<63>to<74>no<6E>causality<74>at<61>all,<2C>or<6F>to<74>a<EFBFBD>non-standard<72>type<70>of<6F>causality?<3F> <01>"P r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>did<69>Kant<6E>not<6F>even<65>try<72>to<74>prove<76>the<68>analogies?<3F> h#8 r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>12.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C>Postulates,<2C>B.265-294;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>239-56<35> 8 <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>nature<72>and<6E>basis<69>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>denial<61>of<6F>ESP<53>and<6E>other<65>parapsychological<61> <01>'<27> # <00>phenomena?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>outer<65>experience<63>provide<64>the<68>basis<69>of<6F>inner<65>experience<63>rather<65>than<61><6E>vice<63>versa<73>?<3F><> <01>)<29>!% <00>B.276<EFBFBD>77,<2C>278<37>79<37> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Is<49>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>claim<69>that<61>inner<65>experience<63>requires<65>outer<65>experience<63>consistent<6E>with<74>his<69> <01>+d#' <00>position<6F>that<61>outer<65>sense<73>is<69>conditioned<65>by<62>inner<65>sense?<3F><><EFBFBD> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kind(s)<29>of<6F>idealism<73>has<61>Kant<6E>refuted?<3F><>What<61>kind(s)<29>does<65>he<68>endorse?<3F> d-4%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>does<65>the<68>refutation<6F>of<6F>idealism<73>occur<75>in<69>the<68>middle<6C>of<6F>the<68>postulates?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>was<61>it<69>added<65>in<69>the<68>B<EFBFBD>edition?<3F> <20> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Kant<6E>says<79>(B.282)<29>that<61>the<68>reader<65>should<6C>be<62>able<6C>to<74>align<67>the<68><65>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>laws<77>of<6F>nature<72>with<74> <20> <00>the<68>categories.<2E><>Can<61>you?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>don<6F> <04>t<EFBFBD>the<68>modal<61>categories<65>extend<6E>our<75>knowledge?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>this<69>principle<6C> <01> <0B> <00>undermine<6E>the<68>ontological<61>argument<6E>for<6F>God<6F> <04>s<EFBFBD>existence?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>it<69>that<61>consciousness<73>of<6F>my<6D>existence<63>is<69>the<68>immediate<74>consciousness<73>of<6F>the<68> <01> p <00>existence<63>of<6F>other<65>objects<74>outside<64>me?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>deny<6E>Berkeley<65> <04>s<EFBFBD>principle<6C>that<61><74>esse<73>est<73><74>percipi<70><69>(to<74>be<62>is<69>to<74>be<62>perceived)?<3F><><EFBFBD> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>13.<2E> <20>Phenomena<6E>and<6E>Noumena,<2C>B.294-315,<2C>B.346-49;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>257-75,<2C>294-96<39> @ <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>categories<65>do<64>not<6F>apply<6C>to<74>noumena;<3B> <01><13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>concept<70>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>noumenon<6F>is<69>a<EFBFBD>merely<6C>limiting<6E>concept<70>whose<73>function<6F>is<69>to<74>curb<72> <01><14> <00>the<68>pretensions<6E>of<6F>sensibility;<3B><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>reason<6F>is<69>not<6F>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>possible<6C>experience;<3B><> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>soul,<2C>world,<2C>and<6E>God<6F>are<72>the<68>only<6C>three<65>(types<65>of)<29>transcendental<61>ideas;<3B><><EFBFBD> <01>l r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Does<65>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>position<6F>on<6F>the<68>unknowability<74>of<6F>noumena<6E>allow<6F>him<69>to<74><6F>know<6F>that<61>there<72>are<72> T$ <00>noumena?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>difference<63>between<65>the<68>positive<76>and<6E>negative<76>sense<73>of<6F>noumena?<3F><>Which<63>does<65> $ <1C> <00>Kant<6E>use<73>(most)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>Kant<6E>posit<69>things<67>in<69>themselves,<2C><>exactly<6C>?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>price<63>would<6C>he<68>pay<61>for<6F>omitting<6E>or<6F>denying<6E>them?<3F> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>14.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>through<67>Transcendental<61>Ideas,<2C>B.349-96;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>297-326<32> <01> | <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>the<68>immanent<6E>and<6E>the<68>transcendental?<3F><>between<65>the<68> h#8 <00>transcendental<61>and<6E>the<68>transcendent?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>transcendental<61>illusion?<3F><>What<61>is<69>the<68>critique<75>of<6F>transcendental<61>illusion?<3F> 8 r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>transcendental<61>illusion<6F>different<6E>from<6F>empirical<61>illusion?<3F><>logical<61>illusion?<3F><>other<65> &<3B> ! <00>forms<6D>of<6F>error?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>When<65>Kant<6E>says<79>that<61>transcendental<61>illusion<6F>is<69>natural<61>and<6E>inevitable<6C>for<6F>reason,<2C>what<61> <01>'<27> # <00>kinds<64>of<6F>remedy<64>for<6F>this<69>illusion<6F>has<61>he<68>ruled<65>out<75>and<6E>what<61>kinds<64>has<61>he<68>left<66>himself?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>it<69>important<6E>for<6F>Kant<6E>to<74>distinguish<73>reason<6F>and<6E>understanding?<3F><>What<61>is<69>the<68> <01>)<29>!% <00>distinction?<3F><>(Is<49>it<69>finicky<6B>or<6F>fundamental?)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>do<64>ethical<61>questions<6E>begin<69>to<74>emerge<67>as<61>we<77>move<76>from<6F>understanding<6E>to<74>reason?<3F> <01>+`#' r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>does<65>Kant<6E>mean<61>by<62>condition,<2C>conditioned,<2C>unconditioned,<2C>and<6E>series<65>of<6F> x,H$( <00>conditions?<3F> `-0%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>it<69>epistemically<6C>commendable<6C>or<6F>regrettable<6C>that<61>reason<6F>should<6C>seek,<2C>for<6F>its<74>conditioned<65> <00>knowledge,<2C>the<68>unconditioned<65>whereby<62>its<74>unity<74>is<69>brought<68>to<74>completion?<3F><>(See<65>B.364.)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>critique<75>of<6F>Plato<74> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>ideas?<3F><> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>transcendental<61>ideas<61>match<63>or<6F>correspond<6E>to<74>the<68>categories?<3F> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>15.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>Antinomies,<2C>B.396<EFBFBD>398,<2C>B.432-512;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>327<32>28,<2C><>NKS<4B><53> <01> <20> <00>384-435<33><35><EFBFBD>0 <00> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><> <02><04>#<23><04># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>there<72>is<69>an<61>entirely<6C>natural<61>antithetic<69>of<6F>reason;<3B> \ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>are<72><65>are<72><65>only<6C>four<75>antinomies;<3B><> D r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>human<61>reason<6F>is<69>by<62>nature<72>architectonic.<2E><><EFBFBD> ,<12> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>freedom<6F>and<6E>natural<61>necessity<74>(through<67>causation)<29>can<61>exist<73>without<75>conflict<63>in<69>one<6E> <13> <00>and<6E>the<68>same<6D>action;<3B><> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00>̢<EFBFBD><02> <00><><02> <00><><02> <00><> <00>& ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00>5 ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><01> <00><><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00>1 ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><01> <00><><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00>- ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><01> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>an<61>antinomy?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>it<69>differ<65>from<6F>an<61>ordinary<72>contradiction?<3F> <01><17> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>would<6C>it<69>mean<61>to<74><6F> <04>solve<76> <04><>an<61>antinomy?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><18> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Can<61>you<6F>anticipate<74>what<61>Kant<6E>will<6C>say<61>in<69>Sections<6E>6<EFBFBD>and<6E>7<EFBFBD>(B.<2E>518ff<66>)?<3F> l<19> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>price<63>would<6C>we<77>pay<61>to<74>leave<76>the<68>antinomies<65>unsolved?<3F> T<1A> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>we<77>know<6F><77>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>that<61>solutions<6E>exist?<3F> <<3B> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>In<49>what<61>sense<73>are<72>antinomies<65>inevitable?<3F><><EFBFBD> $ x! r<06>#r<06># Ѐ<><D080><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>does<65>the<68>inevitability<74>of<6F>the<68>antinomies<65>reveal<61>about<75>reason?<3F> `" r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>do<64>the<68>four<75>theses<65>have<76>in<69>common?<3F>the<68>four<75>antitheses?<3F> <01> H# r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>role<6C>does<65>the<68>unconditioned<65>play<61>in<69>generating<6E>the<68>antinomies?<3F> <01> 0$ r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>16.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>Antinomies,<2C>B.513-85;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>436-84<38> <01> & <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>solutions<6E>to<74>the<68>mathematical<61>antinomies<65>differ<65>from<6F>the<68>solutions<6E>to<74>the<68> h#<23>(! <00>dynamical<61>antinomies?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>role<6C>of<6F>skepticism<73>in<69>non-skeptical<61>philosophy?<3F><><EFBFBD> 8%<25>*# r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>answer<65>to<74>Berkeley<65>on<6F>the<68>question<6F>whether<65>things<67>exist<73>when<65>they<65>are<72> &t+$ <00>not<6F>being<6E>perceived?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>us<75>to<74>conceive<76>the<68>passage<67>of<6F>time<6D>(and<6E>the<68>reality<74>of<6F>past<73>objects)<29> <01>'D-& <00>prior<6F>to<74>our<75>own<77>existence?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>importance<63>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>repeated<65>claim<69>that<61>conditioned<65>objects<74><73> <04>set<65>us<75>a<EFBFBD>task<73> <04>?<3F> <01>)/( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>resolve<76>the<68>conflict<63>of<6F>reason<6F>with<74>itself?<3F><>Does<65>he<68>use<73>reason?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>*<2A>/) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>reason<6F><6E> <04>solve<76> <04><>its<74>own<77>antinomies?<3F><>Why<68>don<6F> <04>t<EFBFBD>they<65>disable<6C>reason<6F>from<6F>this<69> <01>+<2B>0* <00>kind<6E>of<6F>self-cure<72>and<6E>ensure<72>their<69>own<77>permanence?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>isn<73> <04>t<EFBFBD>any<6E><79>rational<61>solution<6F><6E>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>suspect?<3F> `-<2D>2, <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>would<6C>the<68>arguments<74>on<6F>both<74>sides<65>of<6F>each<63>antinomy<6D>be<62>well<6C>grounded<65>if<69> <00>appearances<65>were<72>things<67>in<69>themselves?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>the<68>world<6C>neither<65>finite<74>nor<6F>infinite?<3F><><EFBFBD> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>freedom?<3F><>How<6F>is<69>freedom<6F>compatible<6C>with<74>natural<61>causality?<3F><> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>transcendental<61>idealism<73>(which<63>Kant<6E>affirms<6D>at<61>B.<2E>518ff<66>)<29>differ<65>from<6F>material<61> <01> <0B> <00>idealism<73>(which<63>he<68>refuted<65>at<61>B.<2E>274ff<66>)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD>& <00> <00><> <20>Day<61>17.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>Ideal<61>of<6F>Reason,<2C>Appendix,<2C>B.595-611,<2C><>' <00> <03> <1C> <00>[B.611-70],<2C>B.670-732;<3B> <01>X ТNKS<4B><53>485-95,<2C>[495-531],<2C>532-70<37>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>transcendental<61>ideas<61>never<65>allow<6F>of<6F>any<6E>constitutive<76>employment;<3B><> ,<12> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>reason<6F>is<69>needed<65>for<6F>the<68>proper<65>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>understanding;<3B><><EFBFBD> <13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>logical<61>law<61>presupposes<65>transcendental<61>law;<3B><> <01><13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>pure<72>reason<6F>contains<6E>nothing<6E>but<75>regulative<76>principles;<3B><> <01><14> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>seriously<6C>(or<6F>in<69>what<61>sense)<29>does<65>Kant<6E>intend<6E>the<68>argument<6E>for<6F>the<68>existence<63>of<6F>God<6F> <01>l <00>at<61>B.599-608?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Is<49>this<69>one<6E>of<6F>the<68>dialectical<61>inferences<65>leading<6E>to<74>illusion?<3F><><EFBFBD> l< <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>God<6F>similar<61>to,<2C>and<6E>different<6E>from,<2C>his<69>theory<72>of<6F>noumena?<3F> T$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>understanding<6E>a<EFBFBD>criterion<6F>of<6F>the<68>truth<74>of<6F>its<74>rules?<3F><><EFBFBD> < r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>the<68>regulative<76>employment<6E>of<6F>reason<6F>necessary<72>for<6F>reason,<2C>for<6F>understanding,<2C>for<6F> $ <1C> <00>empirical<61>knowledge,<2C>and<6E>for<6F>experience?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>regulative<76>principles<65>permissible<6C>when<65>constitutive<76>principles<65>are<72>not?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>a<EFBFBD>heuristic<69>as<61>opposed<65>to<74>a<EFBFBD>regulative<76>or<6F>constitutive<76>idea?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Watch<63>for<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>repeated<65>use<73>of<6F>the<68><65> <04>as<61>if<69> <04><>construction.<2E><>What<61>is<69>his<69>epistemological<61> <01> <1F> <00>point<6E>in<69>saying<6E>that<61>sometimes<65>we<77>should<6C>or<6F>may<61>see<65><65>x<EFBFBD><78>as<61>if<69>it<69>were<72><65>y<EFBFBD>when<65>it<69>is<69>not?<3F> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>18.<2E> <20>Doctrine<6E>of<6F>Method,<2C>Discipline,<2C>B.735-825;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>573-630<33> |"L <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>If<49>today<61> <04>s<EFBFBD>reading<6E>marks<6B>the<68>transition<6F>from<6F>the<68>Doctrine<6E>of<6F>Elements<74>to<74>the<68>Doctrine<6E>of<6F> 8 <00>Method,<2C>then<65>how<6F>does<65>it<69>help<6C>us<75>understand<6E>what<61>Kant<6E>means<6E>by<62><79> <04>method<6F> <04>?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>certify<66>that<61>his<69>methods<64>are<72>reliable<6C>ones?<3F> '<27> " r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>the<68>Discipline<6E>so<73>much<63>devoted<65>to<74>the<68>differences<65>between<65>philosophy<68>and<6E> <01>'<27> # <00>mathematics?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>must<73>philosophy<68>and<6E>mathematics<63>use<73>different<6E>methods?<3F><>How<6F>must<73>they<65>differ?<3F> <01>)<29>!% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>When<65>Kant<6E>says<79><73> <04>[<5B>t]here<72><65>is<69>thus<75>no<6E>real<61>antithetic<69>of<6F>pure<72>reason<6F> <04><>(B.771)<29>is<69>he<68>retracting<6E> <01>*x"& <00>or<6F>only<6C>qualifying<6E>an<61>earlier<65>set<65>of<6F>claims?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>faith?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>legitimate<74>when<65>knowledge<67>is<69>not<6F>available?<3F><>Is<49>it<69>ever<65> x,H$( <00>illegitimate?<3F><> `-0%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>In<49>exactly<6C>what<61>sense<73>does<65>Kant<6E>accept<70>the<68>ideas<61>of<6F>God<6F>and<6E>immortality?<3F><>In<49>what<61>sense<73> <00>does<65>he<68>not<6F>accept<70>them?<3F><>What<61>grounds<64>and<6E>interests<74>justify<66>or<6F>impel<65>him?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Evaluate<74>Heinrich<63>Heine<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>claim<69>that<61>Kant<6E>brought<68>God<6F>back<63>in<69>the<68>Dialectic<69>in<69>a<EFBFBD>way<61> <20> <00>inconsistent<6E>with<74>the<68>Analytic.<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>seriously<6C>(or<6F>in<69>what<61>sense)<29>does<65>Kant<6E>intend<6E>his<69>claim<69>that<61>without<75>the<68>critique<75>of<6F> <01> <0B> <00>reason,<2C>reason<6F>could<6C>settle<6C>its<74>claims<6D>only<6C>through<67>war?<3F><>What<61>other<65>passages<65>suggest<73>aϢsocio<69>-political<61>dimension<6F>to<74>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>reason?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>practical<61>reason<6F>have<76>the<68>right<68>to<74>postulate<74>what<61>speculative<76>reason<6F>cannot<6F> <01>X <00>prove?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>19.<2E> <20>Doctrine<6E>of<6F>Method,<2C>Canon,<2C>B.825-84;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>630-69<36> @ <00><>No<4E>explication<6F>due<75>this<69>week.<2E><>But,<2C>in<69>case<73>you<6F>can<61> <04>t<EFBFBD>break<61>the<68>habit,<2C>try<72>this<69>one<6E>for<6F>your<75>own<77>benefit<69>(not<6F>to<74>hand<6E>in):<3A><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>practical<61>reason<6F>has<61>the<68>right<68>to<74>postulate<74>what<61>speculative<76>reason<6F>has<61>no<6E>right<68>to<74> <01><14> <00>assume<6D>without<75>sufficient<6E>proof.<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>ethics<63>not<6F>part<72>of<6F>transcendental<61>philosophy?<3F> <01>T r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>practical<61>or<6F>moral<61>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>principles<65>of<6F>pure<72>reason<6F>give<76>them<65> l< <00>objective<76>reality?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kinds<64>of<6F>freedom<6F>are<72>we<77>known<77>to<74>have<76>and<6E>what<61>kinds<64>are<72>we<77>not<6F>known<77>to<74>have?<3F> < r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68>same<6D>action<6F>be<62>regarded<65>as<61>both<74>free<65>and<6E>determined?<3F> $ <1C> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Are<72><65>all<6C>of<6F>our<75>actions<6E>both<74>free<65>and<6E>determined<65>in<69>this<69>way?<3F><>Or<4F>are<72>some<6D>of<6F>our<75> <1D> <00>actions<6E>unfree<65>and<6E><64> <04>simply<6C>determined<65> <04>?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>moral<61>argument<6E>for<6F>God<6F>and<6E>immortality?<3F> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Does<65>Kant<6E>think<6E>an<61>atheist<73>can<61>be<62>moral?<3F><>(Does<65>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>moral<61>argument<6E>for<6F>God<6F>make<6B> <01> <1F> <00>faith<74>rationally<6C>permissible,<2C>or<6F>rationally<6C>obligatory?)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>has<61>Kant<6E>united<65>nature<72>and<6E>freedom,<2C>or<6F>natural<61>science<63>and<6E>ethics,<2C>or<6F>speculative<76> <01>!d <00>and<6E>practical<61>reason?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>relationship<69>that<61>Kant<6E>envisions<6E>between<65>his<69><73>propaedeutic<69><63>and<6E>his<69>system?<3F><><EFBFBD> d#4 r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kind<6E>of<6F>metaphysics<63>is<69>Kant<6E>hoping<6E>to<74>do,<2C>and<6E>what<61>kind<6E>has<61>he<68>tried<65>to<74>kill<6C>off<66> L$ <00>once<63>and<6E>for<6F>all?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>Kant<6E>give<76>such<63>short<72>shrift<66>to<74>the<68>history<72>of<6F>pure<72>reason?<3F> &<3B> ! r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><>% <00> <00><><01> <00>
</body>
</html>
<head></head>
<body>
<20>WPC<50>> <00><> <00>Rpu <20>]<5D><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>#<23>k<02>]<5D><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> {<7B>&<3B>[<5B> <0B>i<> <1E><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>>hy<68><79><EFBFBD><16>?NA<12><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>a.%3<><33>=<3D><>{<7B><>4N<34><4E>^<02><><EFBFBD>}<7D>'ȧ<>oaTQ$n<>~ŧ<>!b<>?r<>~[J#L<19>WBL<42><4C><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>iI<69> <20>T<<3B><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>9<EFBFBD> <1C><>[2<><32><EFBFBD>I& <20><><EFBFBD>N5<4E><1A><>W}<7D><>c!<21>8-<2D><><EFBFBD><19>v<1A><><EFBFBD>*c@)<29><><EFBFBD>Sb<53>F<EFBFBD><46><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>49<34><39><EFBFBD>G<EFBFBD>f 5[<5B><>P9<50>hPmx-<2D><>C<EFBFBD>W<EFBFBD><57><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>Z<EFBFBD>gz<67><7A>O)4 Y0<59><30><EFBFBD>(Fc<46><63>i/<2F>"<22><>yb<79> <1D><> ԩDGW<47>xBP<42><50>7<EFBFBD>>"v<><76><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>Z<EFBFBD>&<3B>~<7E><>=<3D><><EFBFBD>{<>'<27><19><><EFBFBD>z<EFBFBD><7A><05>mO<6D><4F>O%<25>:Jc<4A><63><EFBFBD>0pʙR}<7D><>O<EFBFBD>!<21><EFBFBD>eW )<29>:<3A>0k<30><6B><EFBFBD>x<EFBFBD><78><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>KoIq⋼ <20><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>d5<64><0F>H|~<7E>N<EFBFBD>e<EFBFBD><65>'<27><>e#<23><>鲇<EFBFBD><E9B287>:<3A><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>r<><72><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>C>:<3A>U)<29><>)* ~<7E>1<EFBFBD>8Y<1A> 6<>ϟ#<23><>Vl?m<><6D>h<05>hD<68> <20>|lm<6C>p=, <1F>Uӭׯ)<29><>W %<25><>} ; U : : % t 0 <00> z 0 R \ <00> <00> O e 0 S <00> <00> 0 <00> <00> t <00> 0 , <00> ; 0 <00> <00> <00> ~ 0 <00> <00> <00> 0 <00> @ 0 z <00> 0 <00> m 0 <00> <00> <00> 0 O l E <00> 0 <00> <00> <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>! <00>! <00>! n <00> <00>! 0 4 <00>" B <00>" <00>" <00>" w @ <00>( 1 ) 0 P O) U V <00>) 4 <00>) U V * _* m a* 1 x* <00>* U V <00>0 U : 1 1 ?1 p1 U V v7 U : <00>7 1 8 78 U V => U : <00>> <00>> <00>> < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i X <00> Z <20><>6 N u m - L i s t 2 n u m b e r e d l i s t , b l a n k l i n e b e t w e e n i t e m s <00><> . . <00><> <00><>2 <00>1.<2E>3 Ԁ<><D480> <00><> <00><>0 . . <00><><EFBFBD> h <00> <10>6 L e t t e r - R e c L e t t e r o f r e c o m m e n d a t i o n <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><><EFBFBD>Letter<65>of<6F>recommendation<6F>for<6F> <00> <00> <00> XQ' <00><> <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><0E>Suber<65> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E> ( ' 2XQ$ <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> <00> ^ <00> &<3B>8 M e m o - F o r m a l F o r m a l m e m o h e a d e r <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><><EFBFBD>To:<3A><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00>From:<3A><>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00>Date:<3A><><EFBFBD>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><><EFBFBD>Re:<3A><> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><0E><> <00><> <00>Suber,<2C><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E> v P <10><>: M e m o - I n f o r m l J u s t m y n a m e a n d c u r r e n t d a t e <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><> <00> <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><> <00> <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><> j <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>. <00> <00> <10>=8 L e t t e r - H o m e L e t t e r w i t h m y h o m e a d d r e s s a s r e t u r n a d d r e s s <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>235<33>South<74>Third<72>Street<65><74> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Richmond,<2C>Indiana<6E><61>47374<37><34> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>317<31>/<2F>962<36>2533<33><33><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>. R e <10><>, E s s a y g e n e r a l f o r e s s a y s <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Department<6E>of<6F>Philosophy<68><79> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Earlham<61>College<67><65> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Richmond,<2C>Indiana<6E><61>47374<37><34><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Copyright<68>(c)<29>1989<38> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><><0E>Suber<65> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E> <00> <10>#4 L e t t e r - E C L e t t e r w i t h m y o f f i c e a d d r e s s a s r e t u r n a d d r e s s <00> = <00><> <00> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Department<6E>of<6F>Philosophy<68><79> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Earlham<61>College<67><65> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>Richmond,<2C>Indiana<6E><61>47374<37><34><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00>317<31>/<2F>983<38>1214<31><34><EFBFBD> <00><> ` <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> h <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> p <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>February<72>12,<2C>1998<39>! <00><> <00> <00> <00> <00><>' <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <1F> D (# <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>. P M <04><>0 H e a d i n g C h a p t e r H e a d i n g <00><>@ <00>. . <00><><02><> <20><> <00><>2 <00>I.<2E>3 Ԁ<> <00><> Ԉ<><D488><EFBFBD><02><> <20> R & <20><>8 B i b l i o g r p h y B i b l i o g r a p h y <00>0 . . <00><> <00>. . <00><><EFBFBD> L H <04><>6 S u b h e a d i n g S u b h e a d i n g <00> <20><> <00><>2 <00>A.<2E>3 <00><> . . <00><> <00><> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <20> x ? <10>t2 P l e a d i n g H e a d e r f o r n u m b e r e d p l e a d i n g p a p e r <00> <00> <00><> <03> <00><> <00><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00> <00> <00> XQ( <00><> <00><> <00><> <00> y<> X X X <00><> <00> <00><> X<02> <00><> <00><04> <00><> <00><><02><01> <00>X <00><>? <00>" ' <00> <00> <00>*<2A> dE<64><03> <00>*? <00><>? <00>" ' <00> <00>*<2A> dE<04> <00>*? <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>1<EFBFBD><31><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>2<EFBFBD><32><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>3<EFBFBD><33><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>4<EFBFBD><34><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>5<EFBFBD><35><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>6<EFBFBD><36><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>7<EFBFBD><37><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>8<EFBFBD><38><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> HH <00> <00>9<EFBFBD><39><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>10<31><30><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>11<31><31><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>12<31><32><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>13<31><33><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>14<31><34><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>15<31><35><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>16<31><36><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>17<31><37><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>18<31><38><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>19<31><39><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>20<32><30><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>21<32><31><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>22<32><32><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>23<32><33><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>24<32><34><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>25<32><35><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>26<32><36><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>27<32><37><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00><02> <00> <00>28<32> <00>.<2E>+ <00> ( ' 2XQ$ <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> <00> <00> Z <20><>6 N u m - L i s t 1 N u m b e r e d l i s t , n o b l a n k b e t w e e n i t e m s <00><> . . <00><> <00><>2 <00>I.<2E>3 Ԁ<><D480> <00><> <00><>0 . . <00><> <00> <00> <00> XQ' <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>* X<02>K X X X <00><> 8<04> <00><> 8<04> <00><><0E>Weekly<6C>explication<6F>topics<63>&<3B>reading<6E>questions<6E> <00><><EFBFBD> \!\!E <00># <00>Page<67><65> <00>1<EFBFBD> <00>.<2E><0E><> <01> <00><> <00>see<65>\books\<5C>kantkdrv<72><76>for<6F>this<69>document<6E>supplemented<65>with<74>page<67>numbers<72>attached<65>to<74>each<63>entry,<2C>and<6E>other<65>notes̄<73>don<6F> <04>t<EFBFBD>revise<73>this<69>doc<6F>without<75>revising<6E>that<61>one<6E>accordingly,<2C>and<6E>vice<63>versā<61>this<69>one<6E>is<69>for<6F>handing<6E>out<75>to<74>students;<3B>the<68>other<65>is<69>for<6F>me<6D>to<74>lead<61>discussion <00> <00> #| x <00> <00> < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i X<02>x <00>6X @<40> <00>8<EFBFBD> X@ ( <12>U$ <00> <00> <00> <00> d <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>( X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00> X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00> <00> E <00> -<02> <00> <00> E <00> -<02> ( -<02> <00> <00> <00> <00> <00> $ <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X ( ( 3^<5E>$ <00> <00> <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r ;<3B>6% <00><01><> <20><> ~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r <00>U<1A><> <00><><EFBFBD> . <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>/ X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00>0 X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i 2 <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>3 X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00>4 X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i 6 <01> P S P e t e r S u b e r X <00> <00> <00>' ^<5E>& <00><> <00><> ݛ<> <00>7 X<02>K X X X <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00> <00>On<4F>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D><73>(recommended<65>but<75>not<6F>required)<29> <01> <02>< <1E>< <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>relations<6E>among<6E>the<68><65>paralogisms<6D>,<2C>the<68>antinomies,<2C>and<6E> x<02> <00>the<68>ideal<61>of<6F>reason?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>the<68>types<65>of<6F>syllogism?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>transcendental<61>ground<6E>constrains<6E>us<75>to<74>commit<69>the<68> H<04> Тparalogisms<6D>?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>it<69>to<74>exist<73>as<61>subject<63>and<6E>not<6F>as<61>object?<3F> <06> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>validity,<2C>if<69>any,<2C>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>to<74>rational<61>psychology?<3F><><EFBFBD> p < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68><65> <04>I<EFBFBD>think<6E> <04><>be<62>the<68>proper<65>subject<63>of<6F>rational<61>(as<61>opposed<65>to<74> <01>X <00>empirical)<29>psychology,<2C>and<6E>yet<65>be<62>an<61>empirical<61>proposition?<3F> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What,<2C>in<69>a<EFBFBD>nutshell,<2C>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>reply<6C>to<74>Descartes<65> <04><>cogito<74>(viewing<6E>the<68> <01> <00>cogito<74>as<61>an<61>argument<6E>for<6F>Descartes<65> <04><>existence)?<3F><><EFBFBD> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>solution<6F>to<74>the<68>mind/body<64>problem?<3F><> <01> <0B> < < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>are<72>there<72>four<75><72>paralogisms<6D>?<3F> p <20> < < <00><># <00>8 X<02><> X X( X<02>K( # <00>~ <00> ) <00> Z <00>> G o u d y O l d S t y l e A T T R e g u l a r < <00>6X 9 ` ( " C o u r i e r 1 0 c p i <00> H <00> <00>! <00>U! <00><> <00><> ݛ<> 8<04> <00><> 8<04> <00><> <00><> <00><> <00> <00><> <00><> = <00><> . <00><> 8 <00><04><><01> <00>X Ӣ<> <00> <00>8h <1F> ԣ<> <00>( X<02>K X X X <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><> r <00><> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> z <00><> < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> D <00><> <00>Peter<65>Suber<65><72> <00> <00><> r <00><> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> z <00><> < <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> <00> <00><> D <00><> <00><>" U<> <04>, <10> <00><> <00> <00> <00>January<72>5,<2C>1999<39>! <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <20><>@ <00> <00>Weekly<6C>Explication<6F>Topics<63>and<6E>Reading<6E>Questions<6E> <20><> 8 T <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD> <00> <00><> r <00>The<68>questions<6E>arise<73>from<6F>the<68>reading<6E>for<6F>the<68>day<61>under<65>which<63>they<65>are<72>listed.<2E><>The<68>explication<6F>topics<63>arise<73>either<65>that<61>day<61>or<6F>the<68>day<61>preceding.<2E> <00> <00><><02> <00><>% <00> <00><><03> <00><><01> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD>& l <00><> <20>Day<61>1.<2E> <20>Syllabus;<3B>generic<69>hand-out;<3B>from<6F>the<68><65>Critique<75>:<3A>Table<6C>of<6F>Contents;<3B>Prefaces<65>to<74>first<73>and<6E> <01><0E> <00>second<6E>editions,<2C><>A.vii<69>-xxii,<2C><>B.vii<69>-<2D>xliv<69>;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>ix-xiii,<2C>7-37<33><37><02> <00><><EFBFBD><03> <00>Thesis<69>for<6F>explication<6F> <00> <00>:<3A><01> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61><74>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>synthetic<69>judgments<74>are<72>necessary<72>for<6F>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F>experience;<3B> Pl r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>revolutionary<72>about<75>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD><73> <04>revolutionary<72> <04><>idea?<3F> $ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>notion<6F>of<6F>metaphysics?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>positive<76>and<6E>the<68>negative<76>value<75>of<6F>critique?<3F> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>will<6C>a<EFBFBD>critique<75>of<6F>reason<6F>decide<64>the<68>question<6F>of<6F>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F>metaphysics?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><17> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>are<72>Galileo<65> <04>s<EFBFBD>and<6E><64>Torricelli<6C><69> <04>s<EFBFBD>experiments<74>(<28>B.xiif<69>)<29>examples<65>of<6F>reason<6F>knowing<6E>only<6C> <01><18> <00>that<61>which<63>it<69>produces<65>after<65>a<EFBFBD>plan<61>of<6F>its<74>own?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>speculative<76>and<6E>practical<61>reason?<3F><>How<6F>do<64>they<65>differ?<3F> x<1A> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>would<6C>trespassing<6E>beyond<6E>the<68>limits<74>of<6F>experience<63>destroy<6F>practical<61>reason?<3F><> `| r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>differences<65>do<64>you<6F>notice<63>between<65>the<68>prefaces<65>to<74>the<68>first<73>and<6E>second<6E>editions?<3F> H d r<06>#r<06># <00><>' l<03><0E> <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>2.<2E> <20>Introduction,<2C>B.1-30;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>41-62<36> 4 <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>we<77>know<6F>that<61>experience<63>and<6E>science<63>are<72><65> <04>actual<61> <04><>such<63>that<61>we<77>can<61>or<6F>must<73>seek<65> <01> <20>!" <00>the<68>conditions<6E>of<6F>their<69><72> <04>possibility<74> <04>?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>a<EFBFBD>concept<70><74> <04>contain<69>a<EFBFBD>manifold<6C> <04><>such<63>that<61>analysis<69>can<61>disclose<73>it?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>"<22>#$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69><73><02> <00><> <04><><03> <00>7<EFBFBD>+<2B>5<EFBFBD>=<3D><>12<31><02> <00><> <04><><03> <00><><02> <00><>% <00>: <00><><03> <00>synthetic?<3F> <01>#<23>$% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>causal<61>judgments<74>synthetic?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>they<65><79>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>?<3F><> t$<24>%& r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Would<6C>Hume<6D>agree<65>that<61>they<65>are<72>synthetic?<3F><>that<61>they<65>are<72><65>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>?<3F> \%x&' <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>the<68><65>Critique<75>a<EFBFBD><61> <04>canon<6F> <04><>or<6F>an<61><6E> <04>organon<6F> <04>?<3F> D&`'( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>synthetic<69><63>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>judgements?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>they<65>possible?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>they<65> ,'H() <00>important?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><02> <00><> <00><><03> <00><><01> <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>3.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic,<2C>Sections<6E>1-5,<2C>B.33-49;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>65-76<37> <01>*<2A>+- Ѐ<><D080> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>time<6D>and<6E>space<63>have<76>empirical<61>reality<74>and<6E>transcendental<61>ideality;<3B># <01>-<2D>.0 r<06>#r<06>#= # <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>unknowability<74>of<6F>things<67>in<69>themselves<65>is<69>necessary<72>for<6F>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F> <00>synthetic<69><63>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>judgments;<3B> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>a<EFBFBD>transcendental<61>aesthetic?<3F><>(How<6F>is<69>it<69>transcendental?<3F><>How<6F>is<69>it<69>an<61>aesthetic?)<29> <01> <0B> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>intuition?<3F> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>sensation<6F>and<6E>intuition?<3F> <01> p r<06>#r<06># М<> <00> <00><><02> <00><>% <00>9 <00><><03> <00><><01> <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>the<68>matter<65>and<6E>form<72>of<6F>sensation?<3F> <01>X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>pure<72>and<6E>empirical<61>intuition?<3F> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>inner<65>and<6E>outer<65>sense?<3F> X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Exactly<6C>what<61>in<69>intuition<6F>is<69><73>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>and<6E>what<61>is<69><73>a<EFBFBD>posteriori<72>?<3F> @ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>empirical<61>reality<74>and<6E>transcendental<61>ideality<74>(for<6F>time<6D> (<12> <00>and<6E>space)?<3F><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>Kant<6E>saying<6E>that<61>the<68>entire<72>world<6C>of<6F>space<63>and<6E>all<6C>objects<74>in<69>space,<2C>and<6E>the<68>entire<72>world<6C> <01><13> <00>of<6F>time<6D>and<6E>all<6C>objects<74>in<69>time,<2C>are<72><65> <04>just<73>in<69>my<6D>head<61> <04>?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>intuitions<6E>and<6E>concepts?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><15> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>it<69>true<75>that<61>in<69>experience<63>no<6E>question<6F>is<69>ever<65>asked<65>about<75>the<68>thing<6E>in<69>itself?<3F><>(See<65>B.45.)<29> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>Kant<6E>sure<72>that<61>the<68>forms<6D>of<6F>time<6D>and<6E>space<63>do<64>not<6F>apply<6C>to<74>things<67>in<69>themselves?<3F> <01>h r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>must<73>time<6D>and<6E>space<63>be<62>forms<6D>of<6F>intuition<6F>rather<65>than<61>concepts?<3F> <01>P r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>4.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic,<2C>Sections<6E>6-8,<2C>B.49-73;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>76-92<39> P <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>more<72>objects<74>in<69>time<6D>than<61>in<69>space?<3F><><EFBFBD> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>inner<65>and<6E>outer<65>sense?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>sensible<6C>and<6E>intellectual<61>intuition?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>is<69>human<61>intuition<6F>sensible<6C>rather<65>than<61>intellectual?<3F> <01> <1F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>God<6F> <04>s<EFBFBD>knowledge<67>intuitive<76>rather<65>than<61>conceptual?<3F><> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>appearance<63>and<6E>illusion?<3F><> <01>!d r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>concept<70>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>number?<3F> |"L r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>physics<63>make<6B>use<73>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>time<6D>and<6E>space?<3F> d#4 r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>there<72>no<6E>privileged<65>access<73>to<74>the<68>self?<3F><><EFBFBD> L$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic<69>express<73>or<6F>fulfill<6C>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>revolutionary<72>hypothesis?<3F> 4% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>Transcendental<61>Aesthetic<69>an<61>organon?<3F><> &<3B> ! r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Was<61>the<68>conflict<63>of<6F>reason<6F>with<74>itself,<2C>or<6F>any<6E>other<65>source<63>of<6F>error,<2C>found<6E>in<69>the<68> '<27> " <00>Aesthetic?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>5.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Logic,<2C>B.74-101;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>92-110<31> <01>)<29>!% <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>transcendental<61>logic<69>is<69>not<6F>formal,<2C>but<75>has<61>content;<3B><> x,H$( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>judgment<6E>is<69>the<68>mediate<74>knowledge<67>of<6F>objects;<3B><> `-0%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>concepts<74>rest<73>on<6F>functions<6E>of<6F>unity;<3B><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>pure<72>concepts<74>(can)<29>apply<6C><79>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>to<74>objects;<3B> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>thoughts<74>without<75>content<6E>empty,<2C>and<6E>intuitions<6E>without<75>concepts<74>blind?<3F><>What<61> <01> <0B> <00>are<72><65> <04>emptiness<73> <04><>and<6E><64> <04>blindness<73> <04><>here?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>intuitions<6E>and<6E>concepts<74>explain<69>the<68>transition<6F>from<6F>the<68> <01> p <00>Aesthetic<69>to<74>the<68>Logic?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>Transcendental<61>Logic<69>a<EFBFBD>faculty?<3F>a<EFBFBD>science?<3F> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>pure<72>and<6E>empirical<61>concepts?<3F> X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>there<72>no<6E>sufficient<6E>and<6E>general<61>criterion<6F>of<6F>truth?<3F> @ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Given<65>this,<2C>what<61>is<69>the<68>status<75>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>concern<72>for<6F>truth?<3F><>What<61>is<69>his<69>notion<6F>of<6F> (<12> <00>truth?<3F><>In<49>what<61>sense<73>does<65>he<68>claim<69>truth<74>for<6F>his<69>results<74>and<6E>in<69>what<61>sense<73>not?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>analytic<69>and<6E>dialectical<61>logic?<3F> <01><13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>result<6C>of<6F>using<6E>general<61>logic<69>(which<63>is<69>a<EFBFBD>canon)<29>as<61>an<61>organon?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><14> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68><65> <04>clue<75> <04><>to<74>the<68>discovery<72>of<6F>all<6C>pure<72>concepts?<3F><> <01><15> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>Kant<6E>call<6C>the<68>understanding<6E>an<61><6E> <04>absolute<74>unity<74> <04><>(B.92)?<3F> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># Ѐ<> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>concepts<74>predicates?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>h r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>judgments?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>arrive<76>at<61>it?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>he<68>sure<72>it<69>is<69>accurate<74> <01>P <00>and<6E>complete?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>6.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Concepts,<2C>B.102-29;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>111-28<32> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>relation<6F>between<65>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>judgments<74>and<6E>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>categories?<3F><>Why<68> <01> <1D> <00>does<65>he<68>need<65>both?<3F><>How<6F>did<69>he<68>get<65>from<6F>the<68>former<65>to<74>the<68>latter?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>table<6C>of<6F>categories<65>known<77>to<74>be<62>complete?<3F> <01> <1F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>third<72>category<72>in<69>each<63>triad<61>arise<73>from<6F>the<68>combination<6F>of<6F>the<68>first<73>two?<3F> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>categories?<3F> <01>!d r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>synthesis?<3F> |"L r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Are<72>the<68>structures<65>of<6F>cognition<6F>shared<65>by<62>all<6C>rational<61>beings?<3F><>Are<72>they<65>subject<63>to<74> d#4 <00>historical<61>change<67>or<6F>evolution?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>method<6F>has<61>Kant<6E>used<65>to<74>learn<72>the<68>structures<65>of<6F>cognition?<3F><>How<6F>have<76>these<73> 4% <00>structures<65>come<6D>to<74>know<6F>themselves?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>a<EFBFBD>transcendental<61>deduction?<3F><>What<61>is<69>its<74>task?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>necessary<72>to<74>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD> '<27> " <00>project?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>we<77>know<6F>that<61>the<68>categories<65>apply<6C><79>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>to<74>objects?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>(<28> $ r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>7.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Deduction<6F>in<69>the<68>A<EFBFBD>edition,<2C>A.95-130;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>129-50<35> <01>*t"& <00><><EFBFBD> <00><> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><> x,H$( <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>a<EFBFBD>unity<74>of<6F>consciousness<73>is<69>required<65>to<74>ground<6E>the<68>knowledge<67>(or<6F>experience)<29>of<6F> <00><> <00>objects;<3B> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>unity<74>of<6F>rules<65>(concepts,<2C>categories)<29>grounds<64>the<68>empirical<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception;<3B> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>transcendental<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>is<69>the<68>ground<6E>of<6F>all<6C>concepts;<3B> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>empirical<61>consciousness<73>(and<6E>its<74>unity)<29>presuppose<73>a<EFBFBD>transcendental<61>consciousness<73> <01> <0B> <00>(and<6E>its<74>unity).<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>central<61>task<73>or<6F>question<6F>of<6F>the<68>transcendental<61>deduction?<3F><>(Part<72>of<6F>the<68>answer<65> p@ <00>appeared<65>in<69>last<73>week<65> <04>s<EFBFBD>reading,<2C>and<6E>part<72>appears<72>in<69>this<69>week<65> <04>s.)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>is<69>this<69>task<73>important<6E>to<74>his<69>program<61>in<69>the<68><65>Critique<75>as<61>you<6F>understand<6E>it<69>so<73> @ <00>far?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>A<EFBFBD>version<6F>of<6F>the<68>deduction<6F>meet<65>the<68>task<73>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>deduction?<3F><>Drop<6F>out<75> <13> <00>inessential<61>detail<69>and<6E>try<72>to<74>state<74>the<68>question<6F>Kant<6E>is<69>trying<6E>to<74>address<73>and<6E>the<68>answer<65>provided<65>by<62>the<68>deduction.<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>the<68>transcendental<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>the<68>producer<65>or<6F>the<68>product<63>of<6F>the<68>categories?<3F><> <01><15> <00>both?<3F><>neither?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>understanding<6E>a<EFBFBD>derivative<76>faculty?<3F> <01>h r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>understanding<6E>determine<6E>sensibility?<3F> <01>P r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>8.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Deduction<6F>in<69>the<68>B<EFBFBD>edition,<2C>B.129-69;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>151-75<37> P <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>first<73>and<6E>second<6E>editions<6E>of<6F>the<68>deduction<6F>differ?<3F> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>empirical<61>and<6E>transcendental<61>apperception?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>empirical<61>consciousness<73>presuppose<73>pure<72>consciousness?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>deduction<6F>set<65>limits<74>to<74>the<68>valid<69>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>categories?<3F> <01> <1F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>Kant<6E>know<6F>that<61>no<6E>categories<65>apply<6C>to<74>noumena?<3F><>Or,<2C>how<6F>can<61>he<68>know<6F>that<61> <01> | <00>their<69>valid<69>employment<6E>is<69>limited<65>to<74>objects<74>of<6F>experience?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>the<68>differences<65>among<6E>the<68>original<61>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>and<6E>the<68>other<65>(derived)<29> |"L <00>unities<65>of<6F>apperception?<3F><>How<6F>are<72>they<65>related<65>to<74>each<63>other?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>e.g.<2E>synthetic<69>unity,<2C>analytic<69>unity,<2C>objective<76>unity,<2C>transcendental<61>unity,<2C>subjective<76> L$ <00>unity,<2C>empirical<61>unity<74> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>should<6C>we<77>distinguish<73>judgments<74>about<75>objects<74>valid<69>only<6C>under<65>my<6D>subjective<76> &<3B> ! <00>(<28>Humean<61>)<29>associations<6E>and<6E>habits<74>from<6F>judgments<74>valid<69>for<6F>all,<2C>publicly,<2C>objectively?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>preserve<76>the<68>public,<2C><>sharable<6C><65>character<65>of<6F>knowledge?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>he<68>avoid<69> <01>'<27> # <00>the<68>conclusion<6F>that<61>consciousness<73>generates<65>all<6C>there<72>is?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>he<68>avoid<69>solipsism?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>are<72>we<77>the<68>law-givers<72>to<74>nature?<3F> <01>)<29>!% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>should<6C>we<77>distinguish<73>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>consciousness<73>that<61>is<69>the<68>same<6D>in<69>each<63>of<6F>us<75>from<6F> <01>*t"& <00>the<68>self<6C>that<61>is<69>different<6E>in<69>each<63>of<6F>us?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>should<6C>we<77>distinguish<73>the<68>I<EFBFBD>that<61>thinks<6B>from<6F>the<68>I<EFBFBD>that<61>intuits<74>itself?<3F><><EFBFBD> t,D$( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kinds<64>of<6F>self<6C>are<72>there?<3F><>What<61><74>is<69>a<EFBFBD>human<61>being?<3F> \-,%) r<06>#r<06># ЇIf<49>you<6F> <04>re<72>feeling<6E>especially<6C>courageous<75>and<6E>adventuresome,<2C>here<72>are<72>some<6D>more<72>specific<69>questions:<3A><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>analysis<69>presuppose<73>synthesis<69>more<72>than,<2C>or<6F>rather<65>than,<2C>vice<63>versa?<3F> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Does<65>this<69>help<6C>us<75>figure<72>out<75>how<6F>the<68>analytic<69>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>presupposes<65>the<68> <20> <00>synthetic<69>unity<74>of<6F>apperception?<3F><>(B.133<EFBFBD>and<EFBFBD>B.133.<2E>n.)<29><> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>necessary<72>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>an<61>analytic<69>proposition<6F>that<61>nevertheless<73> <01> <0B> <00>reveals<6C>the<68>necessity<74>of<6F>synthesis?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>understanding<6E><67> <04>the<68>faculty<74>of<6F>apperception<6F>itself<6C> <04><>(B.134.n),<2C><> <04>nothing<6E>but<75>the<68> <01> p <00>faculty<74>of<6F>combining<6E><67>a<EFBFBD>priori<72><69> <04><>(B.135)<29><> <04>and<6E>of<6F>bringing<6E>the<68>manifold<6C>of<6F>given<65> <01>X <00>representations<6E>under<65>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>apperception<6F> <04><>(B.135)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>an<61>object<63><74> <04>that<61>in<69>the<68>concept<70>of<6F>which<63>the<68>manifold<6C>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>given<65>intuition<6F>is<69> X <00>unified<65> <04><>(B.137),<2C>or<6F><72> <04>a<EFBFBD>determinate<74>space<63> <04><>(B.138)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>copula<6C>express<73>the<68>relation<6F>of<6F>subject<63>and<6E>predicate<74><65> <04>to<74>original<61> (<12> <00>apperception<6F> <04><>(B.142)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>role<6C>of<6F>imagination<6F>in<69>the<68>argument<6E>of<6F>the<68><65> <04>A<EFBFBD> <04><>deduction?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>missing<6E> <01><13> <00>from<6F>the<68><65> <04>B<EFBFBD> <04><>edition?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>9.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C><>Schematism<73>,<2C>B.169-87;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>176-87<38> <01><16> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>a<EFBFBD>schema<6D>is<69>in<69>one<6E>respect<63>intellectual<61>and<6E>in<69>another<65>sensible;<3B><> l< r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>a<EFBFBD>schema<6D>is<69>necessary<72>for<6F>a<EFBFBD>concept<70>to<74>stand<6E>in<69>relation<6F>to<74>an<61>object;<3B><> T$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>possibility<74>of<6F>experience<63>gives<65>objective<76>reality<74>to<74>all<6C>our<75><72>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>modes<65>of<6F> < <00>knowledge;<3B><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>all<6C>intuitions<6E>are<72>extensive<76>magnitudes;<3B><> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>there<72>is<69>an<61><6E>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>anticipation<6F>of<6F>something<6E>empirical<61>and<6E>sensory;<3B><> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>concepts<74>and<6E>principles?<3F> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>central<61>task<73>or<6F>question<6F>of<6F>the<68><65>schematism<73>?<3F><>How<6F>is<69>it<69>similar<61>to,<2C>and<6E> <01>!d <00>different<6E>from,<2C>the<68>central<61>task<73>or<6F>question<6F>of<6F>the<68>deduction?<3F><>Why<68>are<72>both<74>chapters<72>necessary?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>subsumption?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>a<EFBFBD>problem?<3F> L$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>time<6D>fitted<65>to<74>render<65>concepts<74>and<6E>intuitions<6E><73> <04>homogenous<75> <04>?<3F><><EFBFBD> 4% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>are<72>schemata,<2C>images,<2C>and<6E>concepts<74>to<74>be<62>distinguished?<3F> &<3B> ! r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>do<64>schemata,<2C>rather<65>than<61>images,<2C>underlie<69>pure<72>sensible<6C>concepts?<3F> '<27> " r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>schemata<74>match<63>or<6F>correspond<6E>to<74>the<68>categories?<3F> <01>'<27> # r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>schemata<74>simultaneously<6C><79> <04>realize<7A> <04><>and<6E><64> <04>restrict<63> <04><>the<68>application<6F>of<6F>the<68> <01>(<28> $ <00>categories?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Are<72>there<72>schemata<74>for<6F>empirical<61>concepts,<2C>or<6F>only<6C>for<6F>pure<72>concepts<74>(categories)?<3F> <01>*t"& r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Now<6F>that<61>you<6F>know<6F>what<61>schemata<74>are,<2C>how<6F><77>do<64>we<77>perform<72>subsumption?<3F> <01>+\#' r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>principles<65>match<63>or<6F>correspond<6E>to<74>the<68>categories?<3F> t,D$( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>principles<65>provide<64>rules<65>for<6F>the<68>objective<76>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>categories?<3F><><EFBFBD> \-,%) r<06>#r<06># Ї<> <20>Day<61>10.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C>Axioms<6D>and<6E>Anticipations,<2C>B.187-218;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>188-208<30> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>axioms<6D>of<6F>intuition?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>or<6F>why<68>do<64>they<65>align<67>with<74>the<68>categories<65>of<6F>quantity?<3F> <01> <0B> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>are<72>anticipations<6E>of<6F>perception?<3F> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>How<6F>or<6F>why<68>do<64>they<65>align<67>with<74>the<68>categories<65>of<6F>quality?<3F> <01> t <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>the<68>axioms<6D>called<65><64> <04>axioms<6D> <04>?<3F> <01>\ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>highest<73>principle<6C>of<6F>all<6C>analytic<69>judgments?<3F><> tD r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>highest<73>principle<6C>of<6F>all<6C>synthetic<69>judgments?<3F> \ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F><66> <04>self-evident<6E> <04><>truths?<3F><><EFBFBD> D r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>pure<72>mathematics<63>apply<6C>to<74>objects?<3F><><EFBFBD> ,<12> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD>& <00> <00><> <20>Day<61>11.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C>Analogies,<2C>' <00> <03>{T ԀB.218-265;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>208-38<33> <01><13> <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00>̀<EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>changing<6E>appearances,<2C>and<6E>time<6D>itself,<2C>presuppose<73>an<61>unchanging<6E>substance;<3B> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>our<75>subjective<76>synthesis<69>can<61>be<62>made<64>objective<76>only<6C>by<62>a<EFBFBD>rule<6C>of<6F>causation;<3B><> <01>p r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>analogies<65>(taken<65>together)<29>indicate<74>that<61>all<6C>appearances<65>lie<69>in<69>only<6C>one<6E>nature;<3B><><EFBFBD> <01>X r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>not<6F>all<6C><6C>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>certainties<65>are<72>demonstrable;<3B> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>material<61>idealism<73>is<69>false;<3B><> X( r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Do<44>the<68>analogies<65>seem<65>constitutive<76>to<74>you?<3F> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>the<68>analogies<65>called<65><64> <04>analogies<65> <04>?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>difference<63>between<65>things<67>in<69>themselves<65>and<6E>substance?<3F> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>prevents<74>us<75>from<6F>ordering<6E>things<67>temporally<6C>in<69>different<6E>ways?<3F> <01> <1F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>status<75>does<65>the<68>principle<6C>of<6F>sufficient<6E>reason<6F>have<76>for<6F>Kant?<3F><>For<6F>example,<2C>is<69>it<69> <01> <20> <00>empirically<6C>real<61>and<6E>transcendentally<6C>ideal?<3F><> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Are<72>noumena<6E>subject<63>to<74>no<6E>causality<74>at<61>all,<2C>or<6F>to<74>a<EFBFBD>non-standard<72>type<70>of<6F>causality?<3F> <01>"P r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>did<69>Kant<6E>not<6F>even<65>try<72>to<74>prove<76>the<68>analogies?<3F> h#8 r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>12.<2E> <20>Analytic<69>of<6F>Principles,<2C>Postulates,<2C>B.265-294;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>239-56<35> 8 <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>nature<72>and<6E>basis<69>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>denial<61>of<6F>ESP<53>and<6E>other<65>parapsychological<61> <01>'<27> # <00>phenomena?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>outer<65>experience<63>provide<64>the<68>basis<69>of<6F>inner<65>experience<63>rather<65>than<61><6E>vice<63>versa<73>?<3F><> <01>)<29>!% <00>B.276<EFBFBD>77,<2C>278<37>79<37> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Is<49>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>claim<69>that<61>inner<65>experience<63>requires<65>outer<65>experience<63>consistent<6E>with<74>his<69> <01>+d#' <00>position<6F>that<61>outer<65>sense<73>is<69>conditioned<65>by<62>inner<65>sense?<3F><><EFBFBD> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kind(s)<29>of<6F>idealism<73>has<61>Kant<6E>refuted?<3F><>What<61>kind(s)<29>does<65>he<68>endorse?<3F> d-4%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>does<65>the<68>refutation<6F>of<6F>idealism<73>occur<75>in<69>the<68>middle<6C>of<6F>the<68>postulates?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>was<61>it<69>added<65>in<69>the<68>B<EFBFBD>edition?<3F> <20> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Kant<6E>says<79>(B.282)<29>that<61>the<68>reader<65>should<6C>be<62>able<6C>to<74>align<67>the<68><65>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>laws<77>of<6F>nature<72>with<74> <20> <00>the<68>categories.<2E><>Can<61>you?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>don<6F> <04>t<EFBFBD>the<68>modal<61>categories<65>extend<6E>our<75>knowledge?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>this<69>principle<6C> <01> <0B> <00>undermine<6E>the<68>ontological<61>argument<6E>for<6F>God<6F> <04>s<EFBFBD>existence?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>it<69>that<61>consciousness<73>of<6F>my<6D>existence<63>is<69>the<68>immediate<74>consciousness<73>of<6F>the<68> <01> p <00>existence<63>of<6F>other<65>objects<74>outside<64>me?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>deny<6E>Berkeley<65> <04>s<EFBFBD>principle<6C>that<61><74>esse<73>est<73><74>percipi<70><69>(to<74>be<62>is<69>to<74>be<62>perceived)?<3F><><EFBFBD> p@ r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>13.<2E> <20>Phenomena<6E>and<6E>Noumena,<2C>B.294-315,<2C>B.346-49;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>257-75,<2C>294-96<39> @ <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>categories<65>do<64>not<6F>apply<6C>to<74>noumena;<3B> <01><13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>concept<70>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>noumenon<6F>is<69>a<EFBFBD>merely<6C>limiting<6E>concept<70>whose<73>function<6F>is<69>to<74>curb<72> <01><14> <00>the<68>pretensions<6E>of<6F>sensibility;<3B><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>reason<6F>is<69>not<6F>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>a<EFBFBD>possible<6C>experience;<3B><> <01><16> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>the<68>soul,<2C>world,<2C>and<6E>God<6F>are<72>the<68>only<6C>three<65>(types<65>of)<29>transcendental<61>ideas;<3B><><EFBFBD> <01>l r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Does<65>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>position<6F>on<6F>the<68>unknowability<74>of<6F>noumena<6E>allow<6F>him<69>to<74><6F>know<6F>that<61>there<72>are<72> T$ <00>noumena?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>difference<63>between<65>the<68>positive<76>and<6E>negative<76>sense<73>of<6F>noumena?<3F><>Which<63>does<65> $ <1C> <00>Kant<6E>use<73>(most)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>Kant<6E>posit<69>things<67>in<69>themselves,<2C><>exactly<6C>?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>price<63>would<6C>he<68>pay<61>for<6F>omitting<6E>or<6F>denying<6E>them?<3F> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>14.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>through<67>Transcendental<61>Ideas,<2C>B.349-96;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>297-326<32> <01> | <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>distinction<6F>between<65>the<68>immanent<6E>and<6E>the<68>transcendental?<3F><>between<65>the<68> h#8 <00>transcendental<61>and<6E>the<68>transcendent?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>transcendental<61>illusion?<3F><>What<61>is<69>the<68>critique<75>of<6F>transcendental<61>illusion?<3F> 8 r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>transcendental<61>illusion<6F>different<6E>from<6F>empirical<61>illusion?<3F><>logical<61>illusion?<3F><>other<65> &<3B> ! <00>forms<6D>of<6F>error?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>When<65>Kant<6E>says<79>that<61>transcendental<61>illusion<6F>is<69>natural<61>and<6E>inevitable<6C>for<6F>reason,<2C>what<61> <01>'<27> # <00>kinds<64>of<6F>remedy<64>for<6F>this<69>illusion<6F>has<61>he<68>ruled<65>out<75>and<6E>what<61>kinds<64>has<61>he<68>left<66>himself?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>it<69>important<6E>for<6F>Kant<6E>to<74>distinguish<73>reason<6F>and<6E>understanding?<3F><>What<61>is<69>the<68> <01>)<29>!% <00>distinction?<3F><>(Is<49>it<69>finicky<6B>or<6F>fundamental?)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>do<64>ethical<61>questions<6E>begin<69>to<74>emerge<67>as<61>we<77>move<76>from<6F>understanding<6E>to<74>reason?<3F> <01>+`#' r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>does<65>Kant<6E>mean<61>by<62>condition,<2C>conditioned,<2C>unconditioned,<2C>and<6E>series<65>of<6F> x,H$( <00>conditions?<3F> `-0%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Is<49>it<69>epistemically<6C>commendable<6C>or<6F>regrettable<6C>that<61>reason<6F>should<6C>seek,<2C>for<6F>its<74>conditioned<65> <00>knowledge,<2C>the<68>unconditioned<65>whereby<62>its<74>unity<74>is<69>brought<68>to<74>completion?<3F><>(See<65>B.364.)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>critique<75>of<6F>Plato<74> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>ideas?<3F><> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>transcendental<61>ideas<61>match<63>or<6F>correspond<6E>to<74>the<68>categories?<3F> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>15.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>Antinomies,<2C>B.396<EFBFBD>398,<2C>B.432-512;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>327<32>28,<2C><>NKS<4B><53> <01> <20> <00>384-435<33><35><EFBFBD>0 <00> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><> <02><04>#<23><04># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>there<72>is<69>an<61>entirely<6C>natural<61>antithetic<69>of<6F>reason;<3B> \ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>are<72><65>are<72><65>only<6C>four<75>antinomies;<3B><> D r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>human<61>reason<6F>is<69>by<62>nature<72>architectonic.<2E><><EFBFBD> ,<12> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>freedom<6F>and<6E>natural<61>necessity<74>(through<67>causation)<29>can<61>exist<73>without<75>conflict<63>in<69>one<6E> <13> <00>and<6E>the<68>same<6D>action;<3B><> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00>̢<EFBFBD><02> <00><><02> <00><><02> <00><> <00>& ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00>5 ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><01> <00><><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00>1 ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><01> <00><><03> <00><> <00> <00><> <00>- ;<3B>L <00> 8h <1F> <00><><01> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>an<61>antinomy?<3F><>How<6F>does<65>it<69>differ<65>from<6F>an<61>ordinary<72>contradiction?<3F> <01><17> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>would<6C>it<69>mean<61>to<74><6F> <04>solve<76> <04><>an<61>antinomy?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01><18> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Can<61>you<6F>anticipate<74>what<61>Kant<6E>will<6C>say<61>in<69>Sections<6E>6<EFBFBD>and<6E>7<EFBFBD>(B.<2E>518ff<66>)?<3F> l<19> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>price<63>would<6C>we<77>pay<61>to<74>leave<76>the<68>antinomies<65>unsolved?<3F> T<1A> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>we<77>know<6F><77>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>that<61>solutions<6E>exist?<3F> <<3B> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>In<49>what<61>sense<73>are<72>antinomies<65>inevitable?<3F><><EFBFBD> $ x! r<06>#r<06># Ѐ<><D080><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>does<65>the<68>inevitability<74>of<6F>the<68>antinomies<65>reveal<61>about<75>reason?<3F> `" r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>do<64>the<68>four<75>theses<65>have<76>in<69>common?<3F>the<68>four<75>antitheses?<3F> <01> H# r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>role<6C>does<65>the<68>unconditioned<65>play<61>in<69>generating<6E>the<68>antinomies?<3F> <01> 0$ r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>16.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>Antinomies,<2C>B.513-85;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>436-84<38> <01> & <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>do<64>the<68>solutions<6E>to<74>the<68>mathematical<61>antinomies<65>differ<65>from<6F>the<68>solutions<6E>to<74>the<68> h#<23>(! <00>dynamical<61>antinomies?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>role<6C>of<6F>skepticism<73>in<69>non-skeptical<61>philosophy?<3F><><EFBFBD> 8%<25>*# r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>answer<65>to<74>Berkeley<65>on<6F>the<68>question<6F>whether<65>things<67>exist<73>when<65>they<65>are<72> &t+$ <00>not<6F>being<6E>perceived?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>allow<6F>us<75>to<74>conceive<76>the<68>passage<67>of<6F>time<6D>(and<6E>the<68>reality<74>of<6F>past<73>objects)<29> <01>'D-& <00>prior<6F>to<74>our<75>own<77>existence?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>importance<63>of<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>repeated<65>claim<69>that<61>conditioned<65>objects<74><73> <04>set<65>us<75>a<EFBFBD>task<73> <04>?<3F> <01>)/( r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>resolve<76>the<68>conflict<63>of<6F>reason<6F>with<74>itself?<3F><>Does<65>he<68>use<73>reason?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01>*<2A>/) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>reason<6F><6E> <04>solve<76> <04><>its<74>own<77>antinomies?<3F><>Why<68>don<6F> <04>t<EFBFBD>they<65>disable<6C>reason<6F>from<6F>this<69> <01>+<2B>0* <00>kind<6E>of<6F>self-cure<72>and<6E>ensure<72>their<69>own<77>permanence?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Why<68>isn<73> <04>t<EFBFBD>any<6E><79>rational<61>solution<6F><6E>a<EFBFBD>priori<72>suspect?<3F> `-<2D>2, <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>would<6C>the<68>arguments<74>on<6F>both<74>sides<65>of<6F>each<63>antinomy<6D>be<62>well<6C>grounded<65>if<69> <00>appearances<65>were<72>things<67>in<69>themselves?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>the<68>world<6C>neither<65>finite<74>nor<6F>infinite?<3F><><EFBFBD> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>freedom?<3F><>How<6F>is<69>freedom<6F>compatible<6C>with<74>natural<61>causality?<3F><> <01> <20> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>transcendental<61>idealism<73>(which<63>Kant<6E>affirms<6D>at<61>B.<2E>518ff<66>)<29>differ<65>from<6F>material<61> <01> <0B> <00>idealism<73>(which<63>he<68>refuted<65>at<61>B.<2E>274ff<66>)?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD>& <00> <00><> <20>Day<61>17.<2E> <20>Transcendental<61>Dialectic,<2C>Ideal<61>of<6F>Reason,<2C>Appendix,<2C>B.595-611,<2C><>' <00> <03> <1C> <00>[B.611-70],<2C>B.670-732;<3B> <01>X ТNKS<4B><53>485-95,<2C>[495-531],<2C>532-70<37>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one):<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Theses<65>to<74>explicate<74>(pick<63>one)<29><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>transcendental<61>ideas<61>never<65>allow<6F>of<6F>any<6E>constitutive<76>employment;<3B><> ,<12> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>reason<6F>is<69>needed<65>for<6F>the<68>proper<65>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>understanding;<3B><><EFBFBD> <13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>logical<61>law<61>presupposes<65>transcendental<61>law;<3B><> <01><13> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>pure<72>reason<6F>contains<6E>nothing<6E>but<75>regulative<76>principles;<3B><> <01><14> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>seriously<6C>(or<6F>in<69>what<61>sense)<29>does<65>Kant<6E>intend<6E>the<68>argument<6E>for<6F>the<68>existence<63>of<6F>God<6F> <01>l <00>at<61>B.599-608?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Is<49>this<69>one<6E>of<6F>the<68>dialectical<61>inferences<65>leading<6E>to<74>illusion?<3F><><EFBFBD> l< <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>God<6F>similar<61>to,<2C>and<6E>different<6E>from,<2C>his<69>theory<72>of<6F>noumena?<3F> T$ r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>is<69>the<68>unity<74>of<6F>understanding<6E>a<EFBFBD>criterion<6F>of<6F>the<68>truth<74>of<6F>its<74>rules?<3F><><EFBFBD> < r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>the<68>regulative<76>employment<6E>of<6F>reason<6F>necessary<72>for<6F>reason,<2C>for<6F>understanding,<2C>for<6F> $ <1C> <00>empirical<61>knowledge,<2C>and<6E>for<6F>experience?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>are<72>regulative<76>principles<65>permissible<6C>when<65>constitutive<76>principles<65>are<72>not?<3F> <01> <1D> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>a<EFBFBD>heuristic<69>as<61>opposed<65>to<74>a<EFBFBD>regulative<76>or<6F>constitutive<76>idea?<3F><><EFBFBD> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Watch<63>for<6F>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>repeated<65>use<73>of<6F>the<68><65> <04>as<61>if<69> <04><>construction.<2E><>What<61>is<69>his<69>epistemological<61> <01> <1F> <00>point<6E>in<69>saying<6E>that<61>sometimes<65>we<77>should<6C>or<6F>may<61>see<65><65>x<EFBFBD><78>as<61>if<69>it<69>were<72><65>y<EFBFBD>when<65>it<69>is<69>not?<3F> <01> | r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>18.<2E> <20>Doctrine<6E>of<6F>Method,<2C>Discipline,<2C>B.735-825;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>573-630<33> |"L <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>If<49>today<61> <04>s<EFBFBD>reading<6E>marks<6B>the<68>transition<6F>from<6F>the<68>Doctrine<6E>of<6F>Elements<74>to<74>the<68>Doctrine<6E>of<6F> 8 <00>Method,<2C>then<65>how<6F>does<65>it<69>help<6C>us<75>understand<6E>what<61>Kant<6E>means<6E>by<62><79> <04>method<6F> <04>?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>Kant<6E>certify<66>that<61>his<69>methods<64>are<72>reliable<6C>ones?<3F> '<27> " r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>the<68>Discipline<6E>so<73>much<63>devoted<65>to<74>the<68>differences<65>between<65>philosophy<68>and<6E> <01>'<27> # <00>mathematics?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>must<73>philosophy<68>and<6E>mathematics<63>use<73>different<6E>methods?<3F><>How<6F>must<73>they<65>differ?<3F> <01>)<29>!% r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>When<65>Kant<6E>says<79><73> <04>[<5B>t]here<72><65>is<69>thus<75>no<6E>real<61>antithetic<69>of<6F>pure<72>reason<6F> <04><>(B.771)<29>is<69>he<68>retracting<6E> <01>*x"& <00>or<6F>only<6C>qualifying<6E>an<61>earlier<65>set<65>of<6F>claims?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>faith?<3F><>Why<68>is<69>it<69>legitimate<74>when<65>knowledge<67>is<69>not<6F>available?<3F><>Is<49>it<69>ever<65> x,H$( <00>illegitimate?<3F><> `-0%) r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>In<49>exactly<6C>what<61>sense<73>does<65>Kant<6E>accept<70>the<68>ideas<61>of<6F>God<6F>and<6E>immortality?<3F><>In<49>what<61>sense<73> <00>does<65>he<68>not<6F>accept<70>them?<3F><>What<61>grounds<64>and<6E>interests<74>justify<66>or<6F>impel<65>him?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Evaluate<74>Heinrich<63>Heine<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>claim<69>that<61>Kant<6E>brought<68>God<6F>back<63>in<69>the<68>Dialectic<69>in<69>a<EFBFBD>way<61> <20> <00>inconsistent<6E>with<74>the<68>Analytic.<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>seriously<6C>(or<6F>in<69>what<61>sense)<29>does<65>Kant<6E>intend<6E>his<69>claim<69>that<61>without<75>the<68>critique<75>of<6F> <01> <0B> <00>reason,<2C>reason<6F>could<6C>settle<6C>its<74>claims<6D>only<6C>through<67>war?<3F><>What<61>other<65>passages<65>suggest<73>aϢsocio<69>-political<61>dimension<6F>to<74>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>theory<72>of<6F>reason?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>practical<61>reason<6F>have<76>the<68>right<68>to<74>postulate<74>what<61>speculative<76>reason<6F>cannot<6F> <01>X <00>prove?<3F><><EFBFBD> r<06>#r<06># <00><><EFBFBD> <20>Day<61>19.<2E> <20>Doctrine<6E>of<6F>Method,<2C>Canon,<2C>B.825-84;<3B><>NKS<4B><53>630-69<36> @ <00><>No<4E>explication<6F>due<75>this<69>week.<2E><>But,<2C>in<69>case<73>you<6F>can<61> <04>t<EFBFBD>break<61>the<68>habit,<2C>try<72>this<69>one<6E>for<6F>your<75>own<77>benefit<69>(not<6F>to<74>hand<6E>in):<3A><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>That<61>practical<61>reason<6F>has<61>the<68>right<68>to<74>postulate<74>what<61>speculative<76>reason<6F>has<61>no<6E>right<68>to<74> <01><14> <00>assume<6D>without<75>sufficient<6E>proof.<2E> r<06>#r<06># <00>̜<EFBFBD> <00> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about:<3A><01> <00><><02> <00>Questions<6E>to<74>think<6E>about<75><03> <00><><EFBFBD> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>is<69>ethics<63>not<6F>part<72>of<6F>transcendental<61>philosophy?<3F> <01>T r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>does<65>the<68>practical<61>or<6F>moral<61>employment<6E>of<6F>the<68>principles<65>of<6F>pure<72>reason<6F>give<76>them<65> l< <00>objective<76>reality?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kinds<64>of<6F>freedom<6F>are<72>we<77>known<77>to<74>have<76>and<6E>what<61>kinds<64>are<72>we<77>not<6F>known<77>to<74>have?<3F> < r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>can<61>the<68>same<6D>action<6F>be<62>regarded<65>as<61>both<74>free<65>and<6E>determined?<3F> $ <1C> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><> r <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 <00>Are<72><65>all<6C>of<6F>our<75>actions<6E>both<74>free<65>and<6E>determined<65>in<69>this<69>way?<3F><>Or<4F>are<72>some<6D>of<6F>our<75> <1D> <00>actions<6E>unfree<65>and<6E><64> <04>simply<6C>determined<65> <04>?<3F> <02>#<23># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>moral<61>argument<6E>for<6F>God<6F>and<6E>immortality?<3F> <01> <1E> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Does<65>Kant<6E>think<6E>an<61>atheist<73>can<61>be<62>moral?<3F><>(Does<65>Kant<6E> <04>s<EFBFBD>moral<61>argument<6E>for<6F>God<6F>make<6B> <01> <1F> <00>faith<74>rationally<6C>permissible,<2C>or<6F>rationally<6C>obligatory?)<29> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>How<6F>has<61>Kant<6E>united<65>nature<72>and<6E>freedom,<2C>or<6F>natural<61>science<63>and<6E>ethics,<2C>or<6F>speculative<76> <01>!d <00>and<6E>practical<61>reason?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>is<69>the<68>relationship<69>that<61>Kant<6E>envisions<6E>between<65>his<69><73>propaedeutic<69><63>and<6E>his<69>system?<3F><><EFBFBD> d#4 r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>What<61>kind<6E>of<6F>metaphysics<63>is<69>Kant<6E>hoping<6E>to<74>do,<2C>and<6E>what<61>kind<6E>has<61>he<68>tried<65>to<74>kill<6C>off<66> L$ <00>once<63>and<6E>for<6F>all?<3F> r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><EFBFBD><04><>0 r <00>Why<68>does<65>Kant<6E>give<76>such<63>short<72>shrift<66>to<74>the<68>history<72>of<6F>pure<72>reason?<3F> &<3B> ! r<06>#r<06># <00><> <00> <00><>% <00> <00><><01> <00>
</body>
</html>